Quantcast
Channel: BudgetLightForum.com - Charger Reviews
Viewing all 322 articles
Browse latest View live

Test/review of West Mountain Radio CBA HR (Battery analyzer)

$
0
0

West Mountain Radio CBA HR (Battery analyzer)

DSC_4184

West Mountain Radio have two battery analyzers, this is the small version designed for lower current test.

DSC_4176DSC_4177

The box is a standard box for their battery analyzers with a sticker on saying exactly what is in the box.

DSC_4180

The box for this analyzer contains the analyzer, a usb cable, a test cable, a CD and a manual (Both software and manual can be downloaded).

DSC_4179DSC_4181

In addition to the above I also got the thermosensor and 4 terminal adapter. Recording temperature curves requires the extended version of the software, that has to be bought separately (It is only a license code), this extended software also allows a more test modes. I also got this software.

DSC_4187DSC_4188

DSC_4185DSC_4186

The CBA HR is only a box with a few connectors and indicators. There is a USB-B connector for connection to a PC, two power pole connectors for connection to the battery under test, a 3.5mm stereo jack for connection to the thermosensor and 4 terminal sense wires (Connections in the jack are described in the manual).
The box has a fan and it is always on when a test is active, even if the test is very low power.

DSC_4182DSC_4183

The thermosensor and 4 terminal cable has a NTC resistor with a magnet and two alligator clips for connection.

DSC_5113
DSC_4189

The supplied test cable is a pigtail and must be connection to some sort of battery holder or clips that can be attached to the batteries for test.

DSC_5114

My test system uses banana plugs for most connections and I made my own test cable with some power pole connectors, thick silicone cable and banana plug sockets. Using extra connectors will increase the voltage drop, but here I am working with fairly low current and I have the 4 terminal adapter.

DSC_5115

This matched perfectly with a 4 terminal battery holder from China.

DSC_4192

And I was ready to test.



Testing and looking at software

initials

Starting the software I get this screen, pressing the ± icon will open the test start menu (After selecting a filename):

newtest

Where I fill in data about the battery I want to test and the actual test, the data about the battery do not need to be accurate, but helps the software with default values. The “Amplifier” is for the larger CBA and makes it possible to run high power discharges.
The most common test type is “Discharge” that is a standard discharge, but there are many other (See below). For running the same test many times a profile can be used, this will remember all the settings.

When “Start” is pressed the test specification window is closed and the test starts. While it is running the chart will be updated on the screen.

Test3complete

After some time you will get the test completed message. If you want both Ah and Wh, this is the only time it is available in numeric format.

Test3ampssTest3watts

Test3times

The final result can be viewed different ways, depending on selected chart type (Use Test, Chart Properties to change at any time).
It is possible to zoom in/out and move around in the chart. Other charts can also be imported for comparison. Pressing the diskette symbol will save the chart for later.

Test11ampssTest11times

I did a discharge curve at another current and added it to the same chart for easy comparison.



Testing modes

The software has many testing modes, here is a short list:


  • Mission profile. Draw a constant current for a specified time, result is a pass/fail, depending on if the battery could do that.
  • Discharge. Standard constant current discharge
  • Charge monitor. CBA will only record voltage and not do any discharging.
  • Timed discharge.* Discharge battery to a specified percent of capacity.
  • Power profile. Test with automatic increasing current, this shows what a battery can do.
  • Duty cycle. Discharge with pauses, i.e. x seconds on and y seconds off.
  • Constant power.* Power draw will be constant, i.e. current will increase with lower voltage.
  • Multiple discharge. Use a table with current and time.
  • Constant resistance.* The CBA will simulate a resistor.
  • Dynamic. Constant current discharge, but it is possible to manually change current during discharge.
    Requires the extended software



    Export of data

    The program can save in CSV files, but they are not standard format.

    csv1

    The first part of the file contains a header with the test data, but I wonder why it only includes Ah, why not always include both Ah and Wh and preferable in full resolution.

    csv3

    With more advanced tests it will also include more specifications.

    csv2

    After the header follows the data, but not in a numeric format, the quotes says it is text. I would have preferred the numbers to be in numeric format.
    Note: CSV exist in two standard formats depending on country:
    decimal point=. and separator=,
    decimal point=, and separator=;



    Testing for an application

    Because the software can do discharges with pauses or multiple currents (Extended version), it is possible to simulate real word application and see how long a battery will last under specific conditions. Here I will show an example.
    Note: The parameters are selected to get sensible test times, not to simulate real world usage.

    DSC_5116

    This CR2032 is very common for small applications, how much power can it deliver.

    DSC_5673

    The battery holder works perfectly for this type of batteries.

    CR1warnings

    I got a warning when setting this battery about termination voltage, the software was using LiIon termination levels on this custom battery. Not a real issue because I could override the warning.

    CRPowerUIsCRPowerUPs
    CRPowerPIs

    With one test I can generate these 3 curves. The battery can deliver up to 50mA, before voltage drops to 2V (With a fresh battery).

    Lets use this battery in an application that draws 20mA for 20 seconds, at regular intervals, our system works down to 2V. How long will the battery last?

    CR1ampssCR1times

    A constant current of 20mA says 11mAh and that is 33 minutes. That is not really a correct test, because we do not want to draw 20mA constant current, but only for 20 seconds and then some rest time, do this change anything?

    C3ampssC3times

    Here I did a test with 20 seconds on and 80 seconds off to simulate that, it did improve the capacity and time. This time I got 72mAh and 1062 minutes.

    C3timezooms

    The thick line is because the battery recovers between each 20mA discharge, here I have zoomed in on the time curve.

    C4times

    The average current above is 4mA, what about just testing at 4mA?
    The answer is no, the above curve shows 102mAh in 1543 minutes, that is not the correct result.



    Measurements

    LabTest1

    My first test was with a SMU where I can generate a voltage and measure the current while monitoring both voltage and current with high precision. Both voltage and current is precise. And even the lowest current setting (1mA) has a fairly good precision.
    When idle the CBA will draw some current from the battery, how much depends on voltage.

    LabTest3

    Lets try a battery instead and see if it gives the same results. Here the voltage is mostly fixed, but I can change the current.
    If you are going to do many test at same current, it is possible to calibrate the CBA at that current.

    LabTest2

    For the last test I wanted to see how good the 4 terminal connection was. For that I added a 1 ohm resistor in each current lead, as can be seen the voltage is about the same as the battery, i.e. the two 1 ohm resistors are compensated out. Or are they?
    Some more testing showed that it was not a true 4 terminal sense, minus is not four terminal, but has about 0.1ohm between sense and current terminal (Probably the wires).
    There as also another detail: It is important to disconnect sense leads from battery or remove battery, before (un)plugging the mini jack (It will short + sense to – current terminal shortly).

    ri

    The discharge window do also show resistance and that is the internal resistance of the battery (and wires). A fast test shows it is fairly precise.

    CBA%20HR%20voltage%20sweep

    Here I have swept the voltage while measuring the current. The current is fairly stable and it works down to 0.7V

    CBA%20HR%20voltage%20sweep%20min.

    The lowest current (1mA) is a bit more unstable and works down to 0.5V.

    CBA%20HR%20voltage%20sweep%203%2B10mA

    In the table the 10mA curve had tolerances both over and under, how do the curve look?
    As can be seen it has a slight variation with voltage.

    CBA%20HR%20load%20test

    A one hour test at about maximum power. The current drops a bit when the CBA heats up.
    I measured a total of 0.993Ah and 9.831Wh, the rapport from CBA HR said 1.001Ah and 9.830Wh.
    The temperature photos below are taken about 45 minutes into the one hour test.

    VoltageSweepPrecision

    Finding maximum and minimum in the curves and divide by the current gives the maximum tolerance over voltage. It is not surprising that the tolerance is higher at lower current, but it is still good.
    The one-hour test is within 1% and that tolerance will be much smaller if the CBA has time to heat up first. The second line (0.1%) is calculated from 5 minutes to 60 minutes, i.e. after the CBA has heated up.

    Temp4910

    M1: 35,9°C, M2: 51,8°C, HS1: 61,0°C
    The heat is generated in one side of the CBA and the fan is blowing air out.

    Temp4911

    HS1: 61,0°C

    Temp4912

    M1: 53,6°C, HS1: 60,7°C
    The higher temperature can be seen on the side also.

    Temp4913

    M1: 32,6°C, HS1: 59,8°C

    Discharge

    A constant current discharge looks constant on a oscilloscope.

    LoadOnOff

    Using a fast duty cycle test with 1 second on and 1 second off, the load looks like above.

    LoadOn

    A closer look at the on shows that i takes about 10ms to turn the current on.

    LoadOff

    And about the same to turn the current off.



    Tear down

    DSC_5117

    It is very easy to open, just four screws and the circuit board is loose.

    DSC_5118

    The construction has a microprocessor (PIC18F26J53), two OpAmp (LM324 & TLC272C), a current sense chip (INA270) and two mosfets, one on heatsink and one on the circuit board.
    There is placed a 2A fuse on the + connection, i.e. if something goes wrong, this may protect from fire.

    DSC_5119

    There is nothing on the other side.

    DSC_5120

    DSC_5121DSC_5123

    DSC_5122



    Conclusion

    The CBA HR is fairly precise and practical. It can be used to measure battery capacity for smaller batteries, but where it really is interesting is to estimate life time with some specific load, and it can simulate variations in the load.
    The 4 terminal do not really work, but is not needed at 1A, just use thick wires.

My website with reviews of many chargers and batteries (More than 1000): http://lygte-info.dk/


Test/review of Charger LiitoKala Lii-402

$
0
0

Charger LiitoKala Lii-402

DSC_3555

DSC_3556DSC_3557

LiitoKala has some fairly cheap charger that can handle nearly all battery types (Lii-100 and Lii-202), do this one match the other models?

DSC_3552

It arrived in a brown cardboard box nearly without any printing on it.

DSC_3553

In the box was the charger, a power supply, a car adapter and a instruction sheet.

DSC_3558

The charger has usb input for charging and usb output for power bank function.

DSC_5341

The user interface is lots of leds and a single button.
Holding the button down will change current.
Short presses on the button will change battery type.
These selection can only be done before it starts charging.
There is lots of restriction on charge current.

DSC_3559

Specifications are printed on the bottom of the charger (That is fairly common).

DSC_3561DSC_3562

The slots uses the classical slider construction and it works fine.

The slots can work from 32.4 mm to 70mm. This means that very long protected 18650/26650 batteries will not fit in the slots.

supportedBatteryTypes

supportedBatterySizesDSC_3882DSC_3883DSC_3884

DSC_3885DSC_3886DSC_3887DSC_3888
DSC_3889DSC_3890DSC_3891

The charger can handle 70 mm long batteries including flat top cells.
Charge current is on the high side for 10440 batteries.
21700 is a very tight fit.



Measurements


  • Only slot #4 support 2000mA current
  • 1000mA can only be used with one or two batteries on the charger.
  • 700mA can be used with up to 3 batteries.
  • 500mA can be used with all four batteries.
  • The charger will discharge LiIon batteries with below 0.1mA when not connected to power.
  • Usb out will discharge with 0.6mA when not connected to power.
  • When power is connected with a full LiIon battery, the charger will charge with 0.5mA
  • Below 0.1V the charger will not detect a battery, but will charger with about 3mA
  • Between 0.1A and 2.0V the charger assumes NiMH
  • Above 2.0V the charger assumes LiIon
  • Charger will not restart when voltage drops.
  • It will restart charging on reinsertion of the battery or power cycling.
  • Charger uses about 30mA from usb when idle.

Charge LiIon

LiitoKala%20Lii-402%201A%20%28SA18650-33%29%20%231

The charger uses a CC/CV charge curve, but with a fairly high termination current of about 200 to 250mA. It also looks like the electronic is slightly unstable when running in CV mode.

LiitoKala%20Lii-402%201A%20%28SA18650-33%29%20%232

LiitoKala%20Lii-402%201A%20%28SA18650-33%29%20%233

LiitoKala%20Lii-402%201A%20%28SA18650-33%29%20%234

All channels works the same way, the varying amount may be due to different batteries or due to the charger electronic.

LiitoKala%20Lii-402%201A%20%28SA18650-26%29%20%231

This cell is charged the same way, here I included the usb power consumption and it do also vary in CV mode.

LiitoKala%20Lii-402%201A%20%28PA18650-31%29%20%231

No surprise with this cell.

LiitoKala%20Lii-402%201A%20%28BE18650-26%29%20%231

With this old cell the charger is much more stable.

LiitoKala%20Lii-402%200.5A%20%28AW18350-IMR%29%20%231

With a 200mA termination current it is not possible to fill much energy in this worn down cell.

LiitoKala%20Lii-402%200.5A%20%28KP14500-08%29%20%231

The 14500 works better, but it is a high termination current.

LiitoKala%20Lii-402%202A%20%28SA18650-33%29%20%234

In slot #4 it is possible to charge with 2A, the charger do not handle that well, it starts reducing the current very early. The final charge is fine enough, but the time is longer than a real 2A charge would have been.

LiitoKala%20Lii-402%200.5A%20%284xSA18650-33%29

Charging 4 cells at 0.5A works fine enough.

Temp4829

M1: 29,0°C, M2: 30,8°C, M3: 29,7°C, M4: 30,1°C, M5: 36,3°C, HS1: 42,5°C
One of the batteries is a 21700!

Temp4831

M1: 38,0°C, HS1: 40,8°C

PoweronLiIon

Because the charger gives the user time to select battery type, it need about 8 seconds to start.



Charge LiIon 3.6V LiFePO4

LiitoKala%20Lii-402%200.5A%20%28SO14500-LiFePO4%29%20%231

LiitoKala%20Lii-402%201A%20%2818650-LiFePO4%29%20%231

These batteries are charger to 3.65V, this is fine.



Charge LiIon 4.35V

LiitoKala%20Lii-402%201A%20%28LG18650-30%29%20%231

The 4.35V also works fine.


Charge NiMH

LiitoKala%20Lii-402%201A%20%28eneloop%29%20%231

This looks like a voltage termination without any top-off or trickle charge. I am missing the temperature raise the shows the cell is full.

LiitoKala%20Lii-402%201A%20%28eneloop%29%20%232

LiitoKala%20Lii-402%201A%20%28eneloop%29%20%233

LiitoKala%20Lii-402%201A%20%28eneloop%29%20%234

And the same on the other channels.

LiitoKala%20Lii-402%201A%20%28eneloopPro%29%20%231

Here it is also a voltage termination.

LiitoKala%20Lii-402%201A%20%28powerex%29%20%231

With the powerex it is a -dv/dt termination and there is a temperature raise.

LiitoKala%20Lii-402%201A%20full%20%28eneloop%29%20%231

Detecting a full cell is fairly fast with voltage termination, here a bit over 5 minutes.

LiitoKala%20Lii-402%202A%20%28eneloop%29%20%234

In slot #4 the charger can charge with 2A, again it uses a voltage termination.

LiitoKala%20Lii-402%200.5A%20%28eneloopAAA%29%20%231

The AAA cell is also stopped on voltage.

LiitoKala%20Lii-402%200.5A%20%28eneloop%29%20%231

Doing a AA cell at 0.5A is stops nicely due to the voltage termination.

LiitoKala%20Lii-402%200.5A%20%284xeneloop%29

Four NiMH AA batteries are limited to 0.5A charging. The temperature is from slot #3 and the charger probably used -dv/dt charge on that battery.

LiitoKala%20Lii-402%200.5A%20%284xeneloop%29a

The current draw is just below 1.2A on 12V.

Temp4918

M1: 31,3°C, M2: 32,9°C, M3: 32,3°C, M4: 31,5°C, M5: 39,4°C, M6: 31,2°C, HS1: 45,9°C

Temp4919

M1: 39,3°C, HS1: 45,4°C

PoweronNiMH

The charger starts faster with NiMH and uses the usual pauses to measure the voltage.




Usb output


  • Usb output is coded as usb charger (DCP)
  • Only one battery is used for usb output.
  • While usb out is active the 4 leds above the battery shows remaining charge in the battery.
  • Usb output will turn off after 10 seconds with less than 20mA load.
  • The power bank will discharge batteries with about 0.6mA
  • Usb output will only turn on when no power is connected to the charger.
  • Usb output will usual turn on automatic, but can also be turned on with the button


LiitoKala%20Lii-402%20load%20sweep

The usb output can deliver about 1A before the output drops, but it do not look like it has a real overload protection, instead it turns off when battery voltage is too low.

LiitoKala%20Lii-402%20usb%20out%2010ohm%20%28SA18650-33%29

At 0.5A output the usb output works nicely.

LiitoKala%20Lii-402%20usb%20out%205ohm%20%28SA18650-33%29

But at 1A output it has trouble keep the voltage up when the battery voltage drops.

10ohm

The noise is 13mV rms and 117mVpp at 0.5A, when the batteries have enough voltage.

5ohm

The noise is 41mV rms and 197mVpp at 1A



Conclusion

The charger can handle 3 types of LiIon chemistry nicely and also a varity of cell sizes, but I am missing a lower charge current for 10440 cells. A lower termination current would also have been nice.
With NiMH it uses either voltage or -dv/dt termination, this is a good strategy, but I am missing a top-off charge when it do voltage termination.
The usb output only uses one battery and has trouble delivering full power when the battery is partly discharged and the full power is not that high at only 1A.

I will rate it good for LiIon and NiMH, but only acceptable for the power bank.



Notes

Here is an explanation on how I did the above charge curves: How do I test a charger
Read more about how I test USB power supplies/charger

My website with reviews of many chargers and batteries (More than 1000): http://lygte-info.dk/

Test/review of Charger Panasonic BQ-CC65

$
0
0

Charger Panasonic BQ-CC65

DSC_5848

DSC_5849DSC_5850

This is one of Panasonics top models for NiMH chargers, it can charger 4 AA/AAA with individual control and with a usb charger output port it can also charge a phone or other usb device.

DSC_5698DSC_5699

I got the charger in a blister pack.

DSC_5844

The pack included the charger, mains cable and instruction sheet in a lot of languages.

DSC_5852

The charger is powered directly from mains and do not have other power options.

DSC_5855

The user interface is a display and 3 buttons.
REFRESH will start a charger-discharge-charge cycle
DISPLAY will select between voltage, time, mAh and Wh (Last two only for refresh) display.
USB OUT will stop any charging and turn the usb output on.
A normal charge is started by putting the batteries in the charger and do not require any button presses.

DSC_6083

The display has a nice blue background light, but it turns off fairly fast (It is still possible to read the display).

DSC_6076

When putting batteries in the charger it will animate the blocks in this display for a few seconds.

DSC_6077

Then it will show the total number of batteries it has charged.

DSC_6073

When refreshing batteries it is possible to see mAh

DSC_6074

And Wh.

DSC_6086

When usb is selected all the charger stuff is turned off.

DSC_5853

As usual there are some specifications on the back of the charger.

DSC_5851

The usb output is clearly marked with voltage, but not current (It is on the label under the charger).

DSC_5856DSC_5857
DSC_5858

The charger has the typically two level slots used for AA and AAA batteries.

supportedBatteryTypes

supportedBatterySizesDSC_5860DSC_5859



Measurements charger


  • When not powered it will discharge the battery with below 0.03mA
  • If the charger detect an error the display will show error
  • When charging an over discharged battery the charger will show a spanner, it disappears around 1V.
  • The charger use peak currents up to 3.2A
  • Voltage display is within 0.02V
  • Charge will restart charging after power loss, or battery insertion.
  • Power consumption when idle is 0.23 watt
  • Charger reports “FULL” 15 minutes into top-off charge.
  • Charger counts total number of cell charged.


Panasonic%20BQ-CC65%20%28eneloop%29%20%231

The charger stops when the battery starts heating up and then it supplement with one hour top-off charge at around 150mA.
With a single cell the average charge current is about 1500mA, the termination is a bit early for -dv/dt, it could be voltage or a smart algorithm.
Display show 1:33 in charge time. The charging only takes about 78 minutes, this means the charger first reports FULL about 15 minutes into the top-off time.

Panasonic%20BQ-CC65%20%28eneloop%29%20%232
Panasonic%20BQ-CC65%20%28eneloop%29%20%233
Panasonic%20BQ-CC65%20%28eneloop%29%20%234

The other 3 slots looks similar.

Panasonic%20BQ-CC65%20%28eneloopPro%29%20%231

The eneloopPro is charged find.
Display show 2:01 in charge time.

Panasonic%20BQ-CC65%20%28powerex%29%20%231

The powerex is getting old, but it was charged.
Display show 2:12 in charge time.

Panasonic%20BQ-CC65%20%28eneloopAAA%29%20%231

The AAA cell is charged fine.
Display shows 1:40 in charge time.

Panasonic%20BQ-CC65%20full%20%28eneloop%29%20%231

The full cell is detected in about 10 minutes and it also gets a top-off charge.

Panasonic%20BQ-CC65%20%284xeneloop%29

With four batteries the charge current is reduced.
Display shows: 2:55, 2:55, 2:54 and 2:55 in charge time.

Temp5012

M1: 35,9°C, M2: 40,4°C, M3: 42,6°C, M4: 41,7°C, M5: 49,8°C, M6: 41,9°C, HS1: 54,0°C

Temp5013

M1: 35,1°C, HS1: 41,1°C

Poweron

When turned on the charger plays with the lights and shows how many cells is has charged, but that does not delay charging, it is started after a bit over 1 second.

Charge1-2

With one or two cells the charger will use a 50% duty cycle while charging.

Charge3-4

With 3 or 4 cells the duty cycle is only 25%.

Top-off

Top-off charge, it is the same 3A pulses.

Voltage%20sweep%200-1.8

Below 1V the charger uses a “low” charge current, it will first use full charge current above 1V.



Refresh

Pressing the REFRESH button when the charger has started will switch into refresh mode.

Panasonic%20BQ-CC65%20refresh%20%28eneloop%29%20%231

A refresh will charge the battery including the top-off charge, then discharge the battery to about 1V, before charging it again.
Display shows: 1:33, 1907mAh, 2:25Wh

Panasonic%20BQ-CC65%20refresh%20%28eneloop%29%20%232

Display shows: 1:33, 1918mAh, 2:30Wh

Panasonic%20BQ-CC65%20refresh%20%28eneloop%29%20%233

Display shows: 1:34, 1924mAh, 2:25Wh

Panasonic%20BQ-CC65%20refresh%20%28eneloop%29%20%234

Display shows: 1:33, 1879mAh, 2:27Wh

Panasonic%20BQ-CC65%20refresh%20%284xeneloop%29

With 4 batteries the charge rate is slower, but the discharge is at the same speed.
Display shows #1: 2:59, 2013mAh, 2:12Wh
Display shows #2: 2:50, 1906mAh, 2:05Wh
Display shows #3: 2:58, 2006mAh, 2:16Wh
Display shows #4: 2:57, 1953mAh, 2:10Wh
I wonder why I get slightly higher mAh and lower Wh compared to single cell, it might be coincidence or it might be the charger.


Temp5018

M1: 32,5°C, M2: 36,7°C, M3: 36,8°C, M4: 34,2°C, M5: 43,3°C, HS1: 59,3°C

Temp5019

HS1: 36,5°C

Discharge

Discharging uses pwm to control the current, my scope says the current is 390mA.

Discharge2

A bit later, the voltage on the battery voltage has dropped and the pwm is discharging more of the time to keep the current fairly constant.



USB output


  • Usb output will turn off if load is below 100mA for 1 minute.
  • Output is coded as Apple 1A (Why, it is not used anymore)
  • When usb output is turned on the charger will not charge batteries.


Panasonic%20BQ-CC65%20230V%20load%20sweep

The charger can deliver 1.15A before overload protection kicks in.

Panasonic%20BQ-CC65%20120V%20load%20sweep

And it also works the same way at 120VAC

Panasonic%20BQ-CC65%20230V%20load%20test

No problems running one hour at 5V 1A.
The temperature photos below are taken between 30 minutes and 60 minutes into the one hour test.

Temp5028

M1: 31,2°C, HS1: 32,4°C

Temp5029

M1: 30,5°C, HS1: 34,9°C

Temp5030

M1: 37,5°C, HS1: 44,7°C
The charger do not increase temperature much when delivering usb current.

10ohm

Noise is 10mV rms and 211mVpp

5ohm

Noise is 17mV rms and 243mVpp, the noise is low.



Conclusion

The charger will charge AA/AAA cells nicely and it do not have any trickle charge. Because it is sharing one charge circuit between all four slots the actual charge current is a bit high, but average is fine and it uses lower peak current for AAA cells.
The shared charge circuit also means longer charge time with 3 or 4 batteries in the charger.
Capacity measurement works fine, but as always it takes a long time for this type of test, here it was around 12 hours for 4 cells (One or two cells is about 9 hours).

The usb charger part also works fine, but 1A is a slow usb charger and it uses a old coding.

I will rate it as a good charger.



Notes

Here is an explanation on how I did the above charge curves: How do I test a charger
Charger selection table

My website with reviews of many chargers and batteries (More than 1000): http://lygte-info.dk/

Test/review of Charger Japcell BC-800S (8xNiMH)

$
0
0

Charger Japcell BC-800S (8xNiMH)

DSC_3774

DSC_3775DSC_3776

This charger can charge and discharge up to 8 AA/AAA cells with individual charge control for each cell.

DSC_3743
DSC_3744DSC_3745


The charger comes in a retail box. There is some specification on the box.

DSC_3771

The pack contained the charger, a car adapter, a power supply and a instruction sheet.

DSC_3778

The power input is the usual DC adapter.

DSC_3777

The display has 8 battery symbols with animation showing charge or discharge (It must be the same for all batteries).
The display shows “CHG” or “DISCHG” depending on selected function.
Pressing the button for about 2 seconds will start a discharge (or stop it).

DSC_3780DSC_3781DSC_3782

The battery slot are the typical two level construction.

supportedBatteryTypes

supportedBatterySizesDSC_4040DSC_4041



Measurements


  • Power consumption when idle is 0.35 watt
  • Discharges with 0.2mA when not powered.


Japcell%20BC-800S%20(eneloop)%20%231

The charger is charging with about 500mA, but do not stop when the battery is full, first some hours later.

Japcell%20BC-800S%20(eneloop)%20%232
Japcell%20BC-800S%20(eneloop)%20%233
Japcell%20BC-800S%20(eneloop)%20%234
Japcell%20BC-800S%20(eneloop)%20%235
Japcell%20BC-800S%20(eneloop)%20%236
Japcell%20BC-800S%20(eneloop)%20%237
Japcell%20BC-800S%20(eneloop)%20%238

All channels works the same way, termination is not working!

Japcell%20BC-800S%20(eneloopPro)%20%231
Japcell%20BC-800S%20(eneloopXX)%20%231
Japcell%20BC-800S%20(powerex)%20%231

The high capacity cells has exactly the same problem.

Japcell%20BC-800S%20(eneloopAAA)%20%231

With AAA cells the current is lower, but the termination is again late.

Japcell%20BC-800S%20(2xeneloop)%20%2312

With two cell in the charger I got a acceptable termination (only about 30 minutes late).

Japcell%20BC-800S%20(4xeneloop)%20%231234

Again missing termination.

Japcell%20BC-800S%20(8xeneloop)

With 8 cells on the charger this one misses termination, but the one with the thermo sensor did not.

Japcell%20BC-800S%2012V%20(8xeneloop)

The charger uses just below 1A from the power supply, that is marked 1A.

Temp2999

M1: 38,7°C, M2: 41,8°C, M3: 34,0°C, M4: 35,5°C, M5: 36,3°C, M6: 37,5°C, M7: 37,6°C, M8: 38,1°C, M9: 37,5°C, M10: 35,8°C, HS1: 44,5°C

Temp3001

M1: 51,3°C, M2: 48,9°C, M3: 49,3°C, M4: 55,9°C, M5: 55,1°C, M6: 47,0°C, M7: 54,7°C, M8: 53,3°C, HS1: 58,8°C
Batteries are full and waiting for termination.

Poweron

The charger needs about 2 seconds to start up.

Charging1NiMH

The charger is pulsing the current, looks to be about 25% for a cell, lets check some more cells.

Charge123

Here I am measuring voltage on the 3 first cells and as can be seen it will step between them. It only looks like there are four phases, how do it handle cell 5 to 8?

Charge125

Moving the scope from #3 to #5 shows that it run a separate four phase cycle on the four last cells.

TrickleCharge

There is a trickle charge pulse each 80s and it is 1.8 second long (Same size as above), with 2A pulses this gives 45mA in trickle current.



Discharge

Japcell%20BC-800S%20discharge%20(eneloop)%20%231

A single 2000mAh cell can be discharged in about 3 hours and then it is automatic charged again.

Japcell%20BC-800S%20discharge%20(8xeneloop)

The discharge is not fast with 8 2000mAh cells it takes nearly 12 hours. After the discharge the cells are charged again.
The much lower discharge current with many cells is probably to keep the charger fairly cool.

Temp3004

M1: 34,9°C, M2: 33,6°C, M3: 30,7°C, M4: 29,8°C, M5: 29,8°C, M6: 30,1°C, M7: 30,3°C, M8: 30,5°C, HS1: 40,0°C

It looks like the discharge resistors are placed in one side of the charger (Note: charger orientation is changed compared to the other IR picture).

Discharge

The discharge is with a constant current, no pulsing here.



Conclusion

It looks like the charger is missing many more termination with my test equipment connected*, than without, but it did also miss termination without test equipment connected.

The charger is useable, but I will recommend keeping track of time and remove batteries, even if the charger say it is still charging.



Notes

*My test equipment add some resistance between the cell and the charger, i.e. the cell may look older than it is.

Here is an explanation on how I did the above charge curves: How do I test a charger

My website with reviews of many chargers and batteries (More than 1000): http://lygte-info.dk/

"internal resistance" test comparison of several popular chargers

$
0
0

Using some very old AAA NiMh (the Eneloops are 10-years old, the Panasonic may be older)

Zanflare C4

Opus BT-C3100 v2.2

SkyRC MC3000 v1.13 firmware

 

Liitokala Lii-500 Engineer

 

Miboxer C4-12:

  

 

Charger Armytek Uni C2

$
0
0

Armytek Uni C2

DSC_5297

DSC_5298DSC_5299

This charger from Armytek is fairly universal with 4 charge voltages and 3 currents, including a very low one.

DSC_5264DSC_5265DSC_5266DSC_5267

The charger was in a cardboard box with specifications on the outside.

DSC_5294

The box contains the charger, a mains cable, a 12V car cable and a instruction sheet.

DSC_5300DSC_5301

The charger is powered directly from mains or from 12V with the supplied car adapter.

DSC_5305

On the bottom is a very short instruction (Good idea) and some specifications.

DSC_5302

The user interface is two buttons and 10 dual color leds. The dual color is red and green and using both at the same time is kind of yellowish, but the two colors do not mix very well.

DSC_5342

The top led shows the charge current and the bottom four leds the charge state or charge voltage.
When a battery is put in the top led will start blinking shortly after, fast presses on the button at the same side will change current from default 0.5A to 1A to 0.1A and back to 0.5A.
Holding down the button will start one led off the bottom four to blink, click to select charge voltage (This only works for LiIon chemistries).
A press on the button during charging will show the selected charge voltage.
The charger will remember the selected LiIon chemistry and default to that the next time.

DSC_5303DSC_5304

The charger uses the classical slider construction and can handle batteries from 30mm to 71.4mm.

supportedBatteryTypes

supportedBatterySizes

DSC_5756DSC_5757DSC_5758DSC_5759

DSC_5760DSC_5761DSC_5762DSC_5763

DSC_5764DSC_5765DSC_5766DSC_5767


The charger can handle 71mm long batteries, inclusive flat top cells.



Measurements


  • Below 0.3 volt the charge will report fault and charge with about 20mA
  • Below 1.7 volt the charger will assume NiMH, above LiIon
  • Below 3 volt LiIon will be charged with about 140mA.
  • When not powered the charger will discharge LiIon with about 0.4mA and NiMH with 0.05mA
  • When idle the charger uses 0.37 Watt
  • Charger will restart if battery voltage drops below 4.1V on LiIon 4.2V setting.
  • Charger will restart if battery voltage drops below 4.2V on LiIon 4.35V setting.
  • Charger will restart if battery voltage drops below 3.2V on LiIon 3.7V setting.
  • Charge will restart charging after power loss or battery insertion.



4.2V LiIon charging

Armytek%20Uni%20C2%201A%20%28SA18650-33%29%20%231

This is a nice CC/CV voltage charge curve, because the charger first goes into CV mode when the voltage is very close to 4.2V, it will charge fairly fast. Termination current is around 120mA

Armytek%20Uni%20C2%201A%20%28SA18650-33%29%20%232

The second channel look the same.

Armytek%20Uni%20C2%201A%20%28SA18650-26%29%20%231

Armytek%20Uni%20C2%201A%20%28PA18650-31%29%20%231

Both these cells are done nicely.

Armytek%20Uni%20C2%201A%20%28BE18650-26%29%20%231

This fairly old cell is also charged nicely.

Armytek%20Uni%20C2%200.5A%20%28SA18650-33%29%20%231

At 0.5A the termination current is a bit lower (nice).

Armytek%20Uni%20C2%200.5A%20%28KP14500-08%29%20%231

And it chargers a small cell fine.

Armytek%20Uni%20C2%201A%20%282xSA18650-33%29

There is no problem charging two cells at a time.

Armytek%20Uni%20C2%2012V%201A%20%282xSA18650-33%29

It requires about 1A from a 12V supply.

Temp4942

M1: 39,9°C, M2: 41,9°C, M3: 62,5°C, HS1: 88,5°C

Temp4943

M1: 55,8°C, M2: 47,4°C, HS1: 83,8°C

Temp4944

HS1: 108,2°C
There is a part inside the charger that gets rather toasty during charge.

PoweronLiIon

The charger needs about 10 seconds to start, most of the time is used to wait for user current and voltage selection.
It also does a check with a 0.5A current pulse.

ChargingLiIon

While charging it will turn current of to do a voltage check each second.



4.35V LiIon charging

Armytek%20Uni%20C2%201A%20%28LG18650-30%29%20%231

These batteries needs a higher charge voltage and they get it. The result looks fine.



3.7V (LiFePO4) LiIon charging

Armytek%20Uni%20C2%200.5A%20%28SO14500-LiFePO4%29%20%231
Armytek%20Uni%20C2%201A%20%2818650-LiFePO4%29%20%231

These batteries must be charger to 3.6 to 3.7 volt and will drop significantly in voltage when current is turned off, the charger handles this fine.
It can also be seen that the charger uses a low charge current, until the voltage reached 3 volt.



NiMH charging

Armytek%20Uni%20C2%201A%20%28eneloop%29%20%231

A nice -dv/dt charging.

Armytek%20Uni%20C2%201A%20%28eneloop%29%20%232

And the same on this channel.

Armytek%20Uni%20C2%201A%20%28eneloopPro%29%20%231
Armytek%20Uni%20C2%201A%20%28powerex%29%20%231

But these two high capacity cells do not look good, they are only partially charged.

Armytek%20Uni%20C2%200.1A%20%28eneloop%29%20%231

Using 0.1A charge current will prevent a -dv/dt detection from working, this charger do terminate, but a bit early.

Armytek%20Uni%20C2%200.5A%20%28eneloop%29%20%231

Increasing the current to 0.5A works much better.

Armytek%20Uni%20C2%200.5A%20%28eneloopAAA%29%20%231

On this AAA cell it was a bit slow to terminate.

Armytek%20Uni%20C2%201A%20%282xeneloop%29

No problem with two cells.

Armytek%20Uni%20C2%2012V%201A%20%282xeneloop%29

And it requires about 0.5A at 12V to charge two cells.

Temp4950

M1: 39,3°C, M2: 41,2°C, M3: 49,4°C, HS1: 70,2°C

PoweronNiMH

With NiMH batteries it will slowly increase the charge current to the selected level, but it do also make a fast 0.5A pulse before that.

ChargingNiMH

While charging it will turn current of to do a voltage check each second.



Conclusion

The charger is very good at charging LiIon, but that initial 0.5A pulse is problematic with very old cells or small cells (The charger will not charge this type of cell after the pulse check) and means I will not get full use of the 0.1A range, for this reason I will only rate it good.

The NiMH works perfectly for 2000mAh eneloop cells, but I am not impressed with the two high capacity cells.




Notes

Here is an explanation on how I did the above charge curves: How do I test a charger
Read more about how I test USB power supplies and chargers

My website with reviews of many chargers and batteries (More than 1000): http://lygte-info.dk/

[Review]ISDT C4 Smart Charger Review [3A charge, Color IPS Display] (Written+Video+Photos)

$
0
0

Battery chargers might not seem like the most exciting thing to read a review on but trust me this one is different and has a lot of neat features to geek out on. ISDT is an established brand in the Hobby charger market. They have historically been focused more in the RC market but the C4 I have in front of me today is targeted to more common battery sizes such as AAA, AA, and 18650s. This is my first formal charger review, so let me know in the comments what you would like to see in future charger reviews. Thanks to Banggood for sending this to me to take a look at it, this review has not been influenced by the manufacture or seller.

Full Image Gallery:https://imgur.com/a/QpI7Z
Video Review of the ISDT C4: (I am trying to hit 10k subscribers in the next few months, please help out by subscribing.)

Construction
The body of this charger is constructed with a high density gloss white plastic, with the inner carrier where the cells go being a black semi gloss finish. ISDT claims this is a fire resistant plastic, which is nice but one thing I obviously didn’t test. On the rear you have the fan exhaust, power in, USB port for charging a phone or powerbank, and a MicroUSB in for firmware updates. The bottom has slots for cooling air to enter the charger. The front has a nice fairly large color LCD display thats 2.4” IPS display with a wide viewing angle. Itself isn’t touch screen but the touch panel is to the right and contains up and down arrows and a select.




The C4 doesn’t use the standard spring loaded contacts instead the contacts are hard mounted and have a bit of flex to them. Compared with most other battery charges I have (Nitecore, Xtar, etc) it’s a much less flexible in the size of cells that it will accept. I will go as far as saying it’s very picky.

18650 that are any longer then 650mm just will not fit. So most protected batteries are a no go. Unprotected Flat tops, or unprotected button tops seem to fit. Here are a selection of cells I tested fit with.

Sony VTC6 Flat Tops– Fit
LG HG2 Flat Tops– Fit
Samsung 30Q Button Tops– Fit
Sanyo NCR18650B Protected – Too Long
*Nitecore NL1894 *- Too Long
Xtar Protected 10440– Too Long

I didn’t have any trouble with the KeepPower 14500’s, Eneloop AA, Ikea Ladda AA, Duracell Rechargeable AA. Amazonbasics AAA, and Duracell Rechargeables AAA seem to fit.

Limited Capacity
While this charger takes a decent number of sizes of cells (with some popular exceptions) it doesn’t always take very many of them at one time due to how it’s laid out.

Input power is via an included AC Wall adapter. The one in my package has a 2 prong European design and an adapter was included in the shipping package. Having to use the adapter means it’s not the most secure connection with the wall wart hanging off the plug. The charger itself is capable of a 12V or 24V input from an automotive source too and displays incoming voltage in the top right corner of the screen.




Modes and UI
In all modes when the charger is doing its thing you get lots of metrics on the display. You get the mAh that has been put in or discharged from the cell, The time it’s taken, The current voltage, and requested charge rate, the resistance, and temperature. Each bay has its own temperature probe and I believe they are at the positive end of the termal. So it might take a little time for heat to radiate to the sensor if the battery does get hot. It also plots a graph in real time as battery are going through their cycle. This graph scales in real time as time increases.

The C4 is compatible with a wide variety of battery chemistries including NiMH, NiCd, NiZn, Eneloop, Li-Ion, LiHv, LiFePO4.

The main modes of this charger are …

*Charge *- This is the default mode and probably what you use the most. It automatically detects the chemistry of the cell and for most the default charge rate is 1A.

Discharge– Does exactly what the name describes, it discharges the cell in the slot at the rate you choose. 1A seems to be the default speed. Depending on the chemistry the charger will discharge down to 0.9V for NiMH, 1.2V for NiZn, 3.1V for Li-Ion, 3.3V for LiHv, 2.9V for LiFePo4, and 0.9V for eneloop.

Store– This mode charges the battery to the optimal voltage for it’s type of chemistry. This is particularly useful for Lithium batteries who are happiest if they are not going to be used for a while to be stored at between 50-80%. I tested it on an 18650 and it stopped charging at 3.70V. Depending on the chemistry of your lithium battery it could be 3.8V or 3.2V. Storage mode will automatically charge or discharge the cell to get it to the optimal voltage. It’s only available for the Lithium based batteries.

Cycle– Will charge and discharge a battery a given number of times at your given speed. This could be useful on older NiHM or NiCad batteries. Default cycle here is 3 times but the charger will allow you to do this up to 99 times.

*Analyze *- Analyze will charge the cell up to 100% at the rate you choose, then do a full discharge at that rate, and then charge the cell up to full once again. During it’s run it tells you time, cell resistance and capacity in mAh.


*Activate *- This is used to activate a cell where the voltage has fallen below specs or on protected lithium batteries to reset a protection circuit. It uses a small amount of current to “wake” the battery up prior to charging. Caution should be used if using this mode.

*UI*(Video is best for this) is pretty clear and easy to understand. To the right of the screen there is a touch panel with an up, down and select button. They are pretty self explanatory, the up and down allow you to scroll and when you are on an option you want to change you touch the gear selector and then use the arrow keys to make a choice and then the selector to confirm. By default the charge goes to charge mode, in auto detection at 1A when you insert a cell. It gives you 3 seconds (Configurable) to make changes before charging begins. If you want to change modes of a slot while in use the only way to do this is to remove and reinsert the cell. It has a audible alarm and a very large flashing error message if you put a cell in reverse polarity.

The C4 also has the ability to charge another device via USB while charging the batteries in the bay. What’s a little strange is that it seems to prioritize this USB and it will limit current to the batteries instead of limiting the current to the USB port, just something to be aware of. ISDT lists it as 2.1A at 5V for USB charging.

I have some Thorfire 14500’s that this charger doesn’t seem to like. I can’t tell if it’s a bad battery or something else. I know they are not a great battery but they are also not terrible either. My other chargers like the Xtar VC4 charge it without a problem. This charger however will stop charging these at around 75% and act like there isn’t anything in the bay. If it was a bad cell I would expect an error message of some type.

My charger analyzer setup that enables me to graph charging curves isn’t friendly with this charger. The charger is too smart for it and the graphs that I have gotten are not accurate to what the charger itself is doing. I have some new parts shipping from overseas so hopefully that helps a bit for future chargers.

Firmware Update Process
This charge has a microUSB port on the rear that’s used for updating it’s firmware. When my unit arrived I checked the ISDT website and found there was a firmware update available. I was able to download the firmware which came with a windows only flashing program. I had to use AC to power up my charger then plugged it into my PC via USB and then started the program. It was recognized and I clicked the Start flash button in the application. The charger rebooted into a bootloader mode, transferred the file and rebooted. I do wish the log notes were more detailed about what changes between each firmware version. I didn’t notice a tone of difference but there are still a few bugs in the firmware it seems.
https://i.imgur.com/oHTm9nm.jpg

One firmware bug I have encountered is sometimes when I have a battery charging already and I go to insert another one the screen almost goes 100% white, It’s like the user interface locks up. I can’t make it happen regularly but it seems to only happen on the 2nd or 3rd battery insert. I also get some odd percentages as it guesses how charged the battery is at first. This seems to stabilize after about 10 minutes. This was new and I only noticed it after the firmware update I did. Hopefully a future firmware update will fix these issues.

In the Box
The box is nicely constructed and rigid with foam in the bottom and lid. The charger itself was housed in a plastic try with the Euro AC power adapter underneath. I like that they included a glass screen protector like you would put on a smartphone for the screen. It’s should keep the screen free from scratches. https://i.imgur.com/1K7LHwJ.jpg




Pro’s

  • Ton’s of advanced features and options that are all pretty easy to get to on the IPS display with the side touch interface.
  • It’s fast with a maximum of 25W of charging power and 10W discharge power.
  • Easily Upgradeable Firmware on a PC.
  • Well built plastic construction that’s fire retardant.
  • Super obvious reverse polarity alarm
  • Comes with a plastic screen protector you can apply.

Con’s

  • Limited to what cells can be charged by it’s design. No protected cells as the design doesn’t allow for anything longer then the standard 650mm in length. This also holds true for protected 14500 and 10440’s.
  • Small fan is loud and seems to come on based on the power level your charging at not the ambient temp.
  • Shipped with a European power adapter and requires a plug adapter to work in other countries (Included).
  • No manual listed online yet.

Conclusion
This is an advanced charger that has just about every option one would want, but it would be hard for me to recommend this to the flashlight community as someone’s only charger to do it all, because of inability to accept protected cells (Especially protected 18650). Protected batteries are popular on flashlights because they give an extra layer of safety. However for some reason ISDT choose a design that was less flexible on battery length which really compromises the offering in my opinion. I have had a few querkey issues too, mainly with the UI. These should be fixable in future firmware updates.

There are good things about this charger despite that though. It’s easy to use, with a relatively large, easy to read color display. The UI is easy to navigate. It has a wide variety of modes to handle your basic and advanced battery charging like charging, discharge, storage and activation needs. I like that the more batteries you put in it, it doesn’t slow the others down. It also has the ability to charge fast or slow if you want. The charger gives you a lot of data if if your the type of person who likes that thing, and I am.

For charging AA size NiMH batteries this is really a nice charger. It has the ability to cycle, charge, discharge, and analyze cells at pretty quick rates. It can fit 4X AA sized cells at once but only 2x AAAs at once.

For me this is my new AA and AAA charger. I will use it with 14500’s and flat top 18560’s that fit. It won’t completely replace my XTar VC4 as a do all charger but it will supplement it. I really like it’s storage mode for batteries that fit and wish protected cells fit too.

My hope for the short term is that ISDT continues to bring out more firmware fixes for the software bugs that I have noticed. It would be awesome if they had a email list you could join to be notified of new firmware. In the long term I hope that ISDT revises their design for the C4 and comes out with a model that can charge a wider selection of cells including protected batteries, and popular shorter batteries such as 18350, 16340, etc. It would also be nice to see a future model be able to charge 4X 18650 or 2× 26650 at a time. Since this model would most likely be physically larger I would prefer a larger, lower RPM fan to make it a quieter charger.

Thanks again to Banggood for sending this to me to take a look at. They did provide a coupon (coupon Code “C48100”) that takes 8% off the price if you are interested in picking this up.

Test/review of Charger ISDT C4

$
0
0

Charger ISDT C4

DSC_6293

DSC_6294DSC_6295

This charger from ISDT has a lot of functions and can handle both NiMH and all 3 common LiIon types. It can also do NiZn.

DSC_6277DSC_6278DSC_6279DSC_6280
DSC_6281

The charger was in a cardboard box with specifications on the outside.

DSC_6287

The box contains the charger, a power supply, a instruction sheet, a screen protector and some stickers.
I used the screen protector, but as can be seen on some of the photos I was not very lucky with putting it on.

DSC_6289

The stickers.

DSC_6296

The charger is powered from 12V and has a usb output and a micro usb “update connector” for new firmware releases.
The fan is a bit loud and will turn on/off frequently when the charger is working hard, this is rather annoying.

DSC_6297

On the bottom is the specifications and air intake correctly placed at opposite end of air outlet.

DSC_6298

The power supply is a standard 12V 2.5A model.

DSC_6663

The user interface is a good looking color lcd display and a panel at the right. It is possible to touch up/down/select, there is auto repeat on up/down. The up/down function can also be done by sliding.
The touch button works mostly fine, except it sometimes believe I am sliding when I am not.

DSC_6665DSC_6666

The charger will automatic recognize NiMH, 3.6V and 4.2V LiIon batteries, but for the two LiIon types this recognition do first take place around 3.6-3.7V, until then it will not specify what type LiIon it is charging. This also means that discharging or charging to storage voltage the automatic recognition will sometimes fail.
The charger has a lot of modes, I have tested most modes below.

Available chemistries: NiMH, NiCd, NiZn, Eneloop, Li-Ion, LiFePO4, LiHv (In my test I used NiMH, not Eneloop)

DSC_6339DSC_6343

The display looks very nice and includes a lot of information.

DSC_6344DSC_6346

There is no scale on the curve, but it gives a good idea of what is going on.

DSC_6417DSC_6636

DSC_6660

Even the input voltage and the usb output current is monitored.
Holding down on the select button will open the system menu where it is possible to see software/hardware version, reset to factory settings, select language (5), beeper volume (off-low-medium-high), backlight (low-medium-high), capacity limit (on-off), auto start after (off, 3s, 5s), cycle display (off-5s-10s)

DSC_6329DSC_6330

The charger has fixed slots, this limits what size batteries it can handle:
AAA slot up to about 45mm
AA slot up to about 51.5mm
xx650 slot up to about 67mm

DSC_6664

The slot marked AA/AAA can also handle LiIon batteries.

supportedBatteryTypes

supportedBatterySizesDSC_6332DSC_6333

DSC_6338DSC_6334DSC_6336DSC_6337

The charger cannot handle protected cell, but both button top and flat top will usual work. The charger is very limited in supported battery sizes, but with spacers it is possible to handle a few more sizes.



Measurements

Contents
    4.2V LiIon charging
    4.2V LiIon discharging
    4.2V LiIon analyzing
    4.2V LiIon storage
    4.2V LiIon cycle
    LiIon internal resistance
    LiIon activation
    4.35V LiIon charging
    3.7V (LiFePO4) LiIon charging
    NiMH charging
    NiMH discharging
    NiMH analyzing
    NiMH internal resistance
    NiMH activation
    USB output



  • Power consumption is 1.5W when idle with display on and 0.9W with display off.
  • Charger do not assume chemistry on voltage alone.
  • Charger will sometimes automatic select between LiFePO4 and LiIon 4.2V
  • When not powered the charger will discharge LiIon with about 0.03mA
  • Voltmeter is within 0.03V
  • Voltmeter updates both during charge and when the charger is finished.
  • Charger will not restart if battery voltage drops
  • Charge will restart charging after power loss or battery insertion.


layout

The charger has 4 channels and each has two set of terminals. The black numbers are the channels, the white numbers are the references I use in the test.

Test is done with firmware 1.0.0.8
After the testing I updated to firmware 1.0.0.11, it was easy on a Win10 computer. The description of the improvements was not very useful, it just said “optimization” for analysis and NiMH charge.



4.2V LiIon charging

The charger current for LiIon can be selected from 0.1A to 3A in 0.1A steps.

ISDT%200.5A%20%28SA18650-33%29%20%20%237

This charge is a good simulated CC/CV curve.
Display shows: 3214mAh 67mOhm 6:50:30

ISDT%201.5A%20%28SA18650-33%29%20%20%237

At higher charge current it goes faster and the voltage will go above 4.25V.
Display shows: 3274mAh 54mOhm 2:26:10

ISDT%201.5A%20%28SA18650-33%29%20%20%238

How much it goes above depends on the internal resistance of the cell.
Display shows: 3212mAh 46mOhm 2:25:03

ISDT%202A%20%28PA18650-31%29%20%20%237

This cell is not exactly new and the voltage goes above 4.30V, using a lower charge current would have improved this.
Display shows: 2630mAh 75mOhm 1:33:45

ISDT%203A%20%282xAWT18650-30%29

Two cells at maximum charge current, again the voltage is up tp 4.30V.
Display shows: 2842mAh 48mOhm 1:05:22 and 2821mAh 45mOhm 1:08:15

ISDT%203A%2012V%20%282xAWT18650-30%29

Using an external 12V supply it looks like the 2.5A input rating is exactly right, but 4.40V during charge is way to much.

Temp5054

M1: 29,7°C, M2: 30,6°C, HS1: 37,0°C
The charger do not heat the batteries from internal heat, the fan handles this.

Temp5055

HS1: 36,0°C

PoweronLiIon

The charger needs about 5 seconds to start, a few of these seconds are used to wait for the user, other are used to initialize and play a welcome melody.
The charger starts slowly and after a few seconds it will use the selected current.

ChargingLiIon

While charging it will turn current off to do a voltage check each 3. second.



4.2V LiIon discharging

The discharge current can be selected from 0.1A to 1.5A in 0.1A steps.

ISDT%201A%20Discharge%20%28SA18650-33%29%20%238

The charger discharges to 3.1V and it looks like it is adjusting the current trying to keep the voltage at 3.1V.

ISDT%201.5A%20Discharge%20%28AWT18650-30%29

Two cells at full discharge current.
Display shows 2685mAh 2:02:26 and 2677mAh 2:00:10

Temp5062

M1: 27,2°C, M2: 25,9°C, M3: 38,9°C, HS1: 44,2°C
The noisy fan is good at keeping the batteries and charger cool.

Temp5063

HS1: 42,1°C



4.2V LiIon analyzing

For analyzing LiIon the current can be selected from 0.1A to 3A in 0.1A steps. The time shown is for the total operation.

ISDT%201A%20Analysis%20%28SA18650-33%29%20%237

The batteries are charged, discharged and charged again. The charge is not done correctly it is missing the CV part (See below about software update).
Display shows 3260mAh 76mOhm 10:04:29

ISDT%203A%20Analysis%20%28SA18650-33%29%20%20%237

If the selected current is higher than the possible discharge current it will charge at selected current and use maximum discharge current.
Display shows 3021mAh 68mOhm 03:58:41



4.2V LiIon storage

For storage the current can be select from 0.1A to 2.5A in 0.1A steps.

ISDT%201A%20Storage%20failed%20%28SA18650-33%29%20%237

First try at storage failed, the charger guessed it was a LiFePO4 cell and started discharging it, this was very fast!

ISDT%201.5A%20Storage%20%28SA18650-33%29%20%237

This time I selected 4.2V LiIon and the storage worked much better, it charged the battery to 3.7V
Display shows: 1267mAh 57mOhm 01:01:23

ISDT%202A%20Storage%20%28SA18650-33%29%20%237

Next storage test was with a full battery and it was discharged to 3.7V



4.2V LiIon cycle

This cycle the current can be select from 0.1A to 2.5A in 0.1A steps, there is only one current setting.
The number of cycles can be selected from 1 to 66.

ISDT%201A%20cycle%20%28SA18650-33%29%20%237

In this test I did 3 cycles and the charger added a final charging. The CV part of the charge is missing.
Display shows 3074mAh 56mOhm, 21:10:48



LiIon internal resistance

The charger shows internal resistance while charging.

RiLiIon

The first row is done with the same battery in all slots, there is some variation some of it due to varying contact resistance.
For all the other measurements the battery and connection is not touched.
The results looks good, the charger is fairly close to the correct resistance values most of the time.



LiIon activation

The selection said 2A, but the display said 0.1A at 0V (Current will increase at higher voltage).

ActivationLiIon

The charger applies 0.1A for 2½ minute to try resurrect the battery. If the voltage increase the current will also be increased.

ActivationLiIonZoom

A closer look at the current shows it is pulses.

When activation fails the charger report “Battery type wrong”



4.35V LiIon charging

The charger has a special LiIon LiHv type that charges to 4.35V

ISDT%201A%20%28LG18650-30%29%20%231

The simulated CC/CV charging strikes again with too high voltage during charging.
Display show 2845mAh 154mOhm 03:07:29



3.7V (LiFePO4) LiIon charging

Usual the charger will automatic recognition this type of LiIon cell and stop the charger at 3.7V

ISDT%201.5A%20%2818650-LiFePO4%29%20%20%231

Display show 1131mAh 92mOhm 00:57:03

ISDT%201A%20%28SO14500-LiFePO4%29%20%231

Both cells are charged fine and looking at the start of the curve it can be seen that the charger uses a low current below 3V.
Display show 512mAh 118mOhm 00:39:25



NiMH charging

The charger current can be selected from 0.1A to 2.0A in 0.1A steps.

ISDT%200.1A%20%28eneloop%29%20%20%231

In the first curve I have selected way to low charge current for the cell and the charger failed to terminate when the cell was full, the termination was either on time or capacity (The 3001 in the display makes me suspect termination was on capacity).
Display show 3001mAh 52mOhm 30:56:17

ISDT%201A%20%28eneloop%29%20%20%231

A more sensible charge current and the charger uses a -dv/dt termination.
Display shows 1972mAh 51mOhm 2:02:01

ISDT%201A%20%28eneloop%29%20%20%232
ISDT%201A%20%28eneloop%29%20%20%233
ISDT%201A%20%28eneloop%29%20%20%234

It is the same on the 3 other channels (I used the same cell for these 4 test.
  1. Display shows 2092mAh 44mOhm 2:09:25
  2. Display shows 2067mAh 48mOhm 2:07:55
  3. Display shows 2096mAh 55mOhm 2:09:43

    ISDT%201A%20%28eneloopPro%29%20%20%231

    This high capacity cell is handled fine.
    Display shows 2658mAh 68mOhm 02:44:28

    ISDT%201A%20%28powerex%29%20%231

    The charger could not really terminate on this cell, but due to the 3000mAh limit, the charging is fine (Or as fine as can be expected with this old cell).
    Display shows 3001mAh 202mOhm 03:05:38

    ISDT%200.5A%20%28eneloopAAA%29%20%20%231

    Nice charging.
    Display shows 799mAh 95mOhm 01:38:55

    ISDT%201A%20full%20%28eneloop%29%20%231

    A full cell was discovered in 10 minutes.
    Display shows 171mAh 57mOhm 00:10:37

    ISDT%202A%20%284xeneloop%29

    Four NiMH at full charging current, this time the charger was a bit slow to terminate.
    Display shows 1997mAh 63mOhm 01:01:49, 1992mAh 44mOhm 01:01:40, 1997mAh 41mOhm 01:01:49, 1992mAh 40mOhm 01:01:40

    ISDT%202A%2012V%20%284xeneloop%29

    This time the charging looks perfect. The charger uses less than 2A from the power supply.

    Temp5034

    M1: 28,4°C, M2: 30,2°C, M3: 30,7°C, M4: 28,4°C, HS1: 37,6°C
    Not much heat in this picture.

    PoweronNiMH

    The charger need some time to initialize and wait for any user interaction, before starting charging.

    ChargingNiMH

    While charging it will turn current off to do a voltage check each 3. second.



    NiMH discharging

    NiMH discharge current can be selected from 0.1A to 1.5A in 0.1A steps.

    ISDT%201A%20Discharge%20%28eneloop%29%20%231

    A NiMH discharge is to 0.9V and with a final low current discharge.
    Display show 1895mAh 2:01:52

    ISDT%201A%20Discharge%20%28eneloop%29%20%232
    ISDT%201A%20Discharge%20%28eneloop%29%20%233
    ISDT%201A%20Discharge%20%28eneloop%29%20%234

    These discharge are done with the same cell as I charged above.
  4. Display show 1882mAh 2:01:27
  5. Display show 1919mAh 2:03:48
  6. Display show 1927mAh 2:03:46

    Temp5042

    M1: 27,0°C, HS1: 38,9°C
    The fan keeps the charger cool.



    NiMH analyzing

    NiMH analyzing current can be selected from 0.1A to 2A in 0.1A steps.

    ISDT%200.5A%20Analysis%20%28eneloop%29%20%20%231

    The analyze cycle is a charge, a discharge and a final charge again.
    Display show 2175mAh 47mOhm 13:02:55This is a super eneloop cell with more than 2000mA?



    NiMH internal resistance

    The charger shows internal resistance while charging.

    RiNiMH

    The first row is done with the same battery in all slots, there is some variation some of it due to varying contact resistance.
    For all the other measurements the battery and connection is not touched.
    The results looks good, the charger is fairly close to the correct resistance values most of the time.



    NiMH activation

    The selection said 2A, but the display said 0.1A at 0V (Current will increase at higher voltage).

    ActivationNiMH

    The charger applies 0.1A for 2½ minute to try resurrect the battery. If the voltage increase the current will also be increased.

    ActivationNiMHzoom

    A closer look at the current shows it is pulses.

    When activation fails the charger report “Battery type wrong”



    USB output


  • Power consumption is 1.5W when idle with display on and 0.9W with display off.
  • Usb output is auto coding with DCP, Samsung and Apple 1A


usbCurrent

The current display has good precision.

ISDT%20C4%20120V%20load%20sweep

The usb output can deliver just above 2.3A before overload protection trips.

ISDT%20C4%20230V%20load%20sweep

And it is exactly the same on 230VAC (As expected).

ISDT%20C4%20230V%20load%20test

No problem running for one hour with 2.1A output.
The temperature photos below are taken between 30 minutes and 60 minutes into the one hour test.

Temp5031

M1: 38,4°C, M2: 36,3°C, HS1: 43,1°C

Temp5032

M1: 37,4°C, HS1: 57,1°C
I found a hot spot on the charger or at least a warm spot (The charger did not use the fan when I used the usb output).

Temp5033

M1: 37,6°C, HS1: 43,0°C

10ohm

Noise is 172mV rms and 567mVpp

5ohm

Noise is 206mV rms and 850mVpp

2.5ohm

Noise is 148mV rms and 673mVpp

5ohmSpectrum

With the fairly high noise level I decided to check what it contained.


New firmware V1.0.0.11

While I was testing a new firmware was release. I did first update when testing was finished and then I did a few extra checks on the areas where the new release was supposed to improve the charger (Analysis and NiMH charge).

ISDT%200.1A%20%28eneloop%29%20%231%20SW

The low current NiMH charging was not improved, it still do not terminate.
Display shows 3001mAh 40mOhm 30:56:17

ISDT%201A%20%28eneloop%29%20%231%20SW

Normal NiMH charge looks similar.
Display shows 2075mAh 61mOhm 02:08:22

ISDT%202A%20Analysis%20%28SA18650-33%29%20%20%237%20SW

A CV voltage has been added to the initial charge in analysis mode and the discharge mode do not slowly reduce current anymore, instead it drops to 0.5A from there sloly reduce current. It looks like the charge failed, there is no CV phase.
The fan did not stop when the charger was finished, but continued to run.
Display shows 3138mAh 106mOhm 06:10:25

Testing with 2500 volt and 5000 volt between mains and low volt side, did not show any safety problems with the power supply.



Conclusion

This charger has many functions and is easy to use, but it also has a few faults:
Auto recognition of LiIon 4.2V and 3.6V(LiFePO4) do not always work. I have seen 4.2V LiIon stopping at 3.6V and discharge/storage is also likely to fail if started with a partial full 4.2V LiIon.
First version of analysis missed the CV part, next version is better in that respect, but charger malfunctioned, this will probably be fixed in a later software update.
LiIon charge algorithm use way to high charge voltage, but the battery will not be overcharged.
There is also the limit on battery size, some common LiIon sizes requires spacers to be charged in this charger.

Do this charger match the top analyzing charger? The answer is no, it is far behind in settings and precision, but it is much easier to use.

For now I will only rate the charger acceptable.



Notes

The charger was supplied from Banggood for review.

Here is an explanation on how I did the above charge curves: How do I test a charger
Read more about how I test USB power supplies and chargers

My website with reviews of many chargers and batteries (More than 1000): http://lygte-info.dk/


Test/review of Charger Sofirn 8 slots AA/AAA

$
0
0

Charger Sofirn 8 slots AA/AAA

DSC_1566

DSC_1567DSC_1568

This charger is a fairly cheap and slow 8 slot NiMH charger.

DSC_1565

I got it in a plastic bag without any box or instruction sheet.

DSC_1569

The charger works on mains voltage.

DSC_1570

Each slot has a two color led, red while charging and green when finished.

DSC_1571

The back has the usual specifications on it. Do not be confused by the 2.6V, it is individual cell handling.

DSC_1572DSC_1574DSC_1575

The slots are the usual two level slots used for AA/AAA batteries.

supportedBatteryTypes

supportedBatterySizes

DSC_1576



Measurements


  • Power consumption when idle is 0.2 watt.
  • Will discharge battery with 7mA when power is off
  • Charge will restart charging after power loss, or battery insertion.


Sofirn%20%28eneloop%29%20%231

The charger current is fairly low at about 200mA, this means the charger time is nearly 10 hours. The termination looks fine for this cell, as can be seen on the black line the temperature has started rise and then the charger stops.
Stops may not be the correct word, the charger has some trickle charge, the low charge current makes it very easy to see it on the curves, it is around 35mA.

Sofirn%20%28eneloop%29%20%232
Sofirn%20%28eneloop%29%20%233
Sofirn%20%28eneloop%29%20%234
Sofirn%20%28eneloop%29%20%235
Sofirn%20%28eneloop%29%20%236
Sofirn%20%28eneloop%29%20%237
Sofirn%20%28eneloop%29%20%238

The other slots looks the same.

Sofirn%20%28eneloopPro%29%20%231
Sofirn%20%28powerex%29%20%231

The high capacity cells is charged nicely.

Sofirn%20%28eneloopAAA%29%20%231

The AAA cell is charged nicely, the charge current is a bit lower

Sofirn%20full%20%28eneloop%29%20%231

The charger is also very slow at detecting a full cell.

Sofirn%20%288xeneloop%29

The charge current is the same with 8 cells in the charger.

Temp4996

M1: 45,8, M2: 40,8, M3: 38,3, M4: 35,8, M5: 35,5, M6: 34,1, M7: 32,4, HS1: 68,3
The cell closest to the power supply of the charger is a bit on the warm side.

Temp4997

M1: 49,3, M2: 60,0, HS1: 68,4

Poweron

The charger starts in about 2 seconds.

Charging

During charging it will take a short break each minute to measure the cell voltage.

Charging%20voltage%20sweep%200-1.8V

The charging current is depend on the battery voltage and it looks like it is controlled by a resistor.



Tear down

I was a bit curious how the 8 channels was done.

DSC_5861

I had to remove 6 screws and I was inside the charger.

DSC_5862

At the mains input there is a bridge rectifier and a switcher. There is some pins from a capacitor on the other side that is very close to making a short circuit. On the low volt side is about 2.6V and a small switcher that boost the voltage to 4.6V for the microprocessor.
The charger is not a 8 channel charger, but two 4 channels one, each with its own microprocessor that is without a type number.
The microprocessor must have two led outputs, one charge current and one analog input to measure voltage. One of the led outputs can be (and is) combined with the charge current on output. Each channel has a transistor to turn the current on and resistors to limit the current for AA and AAA. For AA it is two 10 ohm in parallel, with AAA a extra 2.7ohm is added in series. The voltage on the battery is measured through a 100kOhm resistor.

DSC_5868

DSC_5863

On this side is a input fuse, the smoothing capacitors, the transformer and the rectifier diode for the low voltage.
There is also all the battery connections and the leds.

DSC_5864

DSC_5865DSC_5867

DSC_5866


DSC_5869

With a slot in the board the isolation distance must be 4mm, it looks like it is very slightly below that.

Testing the power supply with 2830 volt and 4242 volt between mains and low volt side, did not show any safety problems.



Conclusion

The charger charges fine with individual handling of each cell, but there is the detail about trickle charge. As long as the batteries are removed when the are finished (Within a couple of hours to a day) it is not a problem, but leaving them on the charger for weeks is a problem.
The charger is rather slow with about 9 hours for a 2000mAh cell.

I will rate it fairly good.



Notes

Here is an explanation on how I did the above charge curves: How do I test a charger
Charger selection table

My website with reviews of many chargers and batteries (More than 1000): https://lygte-info.dk/

Test/review of Nitecore Intellicharger i8

$
0
0

Nitecore Intellicharger i8

DSC_5986

DSC_5987DSC_5990

This is a simple to use 8 slot charger with usb charging outputs.

DSC_5973DSC_5974DSC_5975DSC_5976

The cardboard box lists lot of specifications, battery types and features.

DSC_5983

The box contains the charger, a mains cable, manual and a warranty card.

DSC_5987DSC_5989

Front and back looks the same on the charger.

DSC_5988DSC_5990

All the connections are on one side.

DSC_5993

The charger has two power connectors, one for mains input (100-250VAC 50/60Hz) and one for 12 VDC input. There is also a dual usb output.

DSC_6634

The user interface is one led for each slot, it is red while charging, flashing red on error and green when done.
They cannot be seen from all angles or in bright light.

DSC_5994DSC_5996

The slots uses the usual construction except for orientation and works well. The springs are strong enough that batteries may fly.
They can handle batteries from 28mm to 70mm long.
This means 21700 is a very tight fit and some protected 18650/26650/32650 will not fit.

supportedBatteryTypes

supportedBatterySizes

DSC_6625DSC_6626DSC_6627DSC_6628

DSC_6629DSC_6630DSC_6631DSC_6632

DSC_6633

The charger can just about handle 70 mm long batteries, inclusive flat top cells.
The minimum charge current is on the high side for 10440 batteries.



Measurements


  • Power consumption when idle is 0.85 watt
  • Will charge a LiIon with 0.2mA when charging is finished.
  • Will discharge a NiMH with 0.1mA when not powered
  • Will discharge a LiIon with 1.4mA when not powered
  • Change between long/short cell at around 56mm
  • Below 0.75V the charger will report error (leds flashing) and charge with about 0.5mA.
  • Above 0.75V regular charging is used.
  • Will assume LiIon above 2.0V
  • Slots on opposite sides will time share.
  • The charger makes small clicking noises when switching power on/off to the batteries.
  • Charger will not restart if battery voltage drops.
  • Power cycling and insertion of a battery will restart charging.


LiIon charging

Nitecore%20i8%20%28SA18650-33%29%20%231

The charge curve is a CC/CV with termination current around 150mA, if the voltage had been correct it would be fine, but this slot charges to 4.28V, maximum allowed is 4.25V.

Nitecore%20i8%20%28SA18650-33%29%20%232
Nitecore%20i8%20%28SA18650-33%29%20%233
Nitecore%20i8%20%28SA18650-33%29%20%234
Nitecore%20i8%20%28SA18650-33%29%20%235
Nitecore%20i8%20%28SA18650-33%29%20%236
Nitecore%20i8%20%28SA18650-33%29%20%237
Nitecore%20i8%20%28SA18650-33%29%20%238

All the other slots also chargers above 4.25V

Nitecore%20i8%20%28SA18650-26%29%20%231
Nitecore%20i8%20%28PA18650-31%29%20%231

These cells is charged very close to 4.30V.

Nitecore%20i8%20%28BE18650-26%29%20%231

This old protected cell would not accept it and the overcharge protection tripped.
The red line disappears at the same time the current drops to 0 (It went up to 5 volt).

Nitecore%20i8%20%28AW18350-IMR%29%20%231

This type of overcharging will stuff some energy into this very old and worn down cell.
Because the cell is shorter the current is reduce to about 0.5A.

Nitecore%20i8%20%28KP14500-08%29%20%231

This cell is also charged with 0.5A and this is also a protected cell, where the protection trips.

Nitecore%20i8%20%288xSA18650-33%29

With 8 cells the charge speed is reduced, both due to time sharing and because I am charging 4 cells on one side. At about 375 minutes one (or more) of the cells are finished and the current is increased.

Nitecore%20i8%2012V%20%288xSA18650-33%29

Using a 12V supply the charger needs a bit above 2A when charging 8 batteries.

Temp5074

M1: 36,6°C, M2: 38,7°C, M3: 38,8°C, M4: 36,5°C, M5: 69,0°C, HS1: 77,0°C
The heat generating electronic are in the bottom of the charger and it looks like this construction if fairly good at keeping the batteries away from the heat.

Temp5075

M1: 48,1°C, HS1: 69,0°C

PoweronLiIon

The charger needs about 2 seconds to start.

Charge2LiIon

When using both sides of the charger it will time share the charging circuit, this will halve the average charge current. This is for batteries mounted opposite each other.

Charge4LiIon

When charging 4 batteries on a side the current will be slightly reduces (1-3 will use full current). This reduction will be for both sides, i.e. one side with 4 batteries and only one on the other side will both use time share (For two batteries) and reduces charge current for all 5 batteries.



NiMH charging

Nitecore%20i8%20%28eneloop%29%20%231

The charger uses the low current setting for NiMH and terminates on voltage. The termination is slightly early, the battery temperature has not started increasing yet. There is no trickle charge.

Nitecore%20i8%20%28eneloop%29%20%232
Nitecore%20i8%20%28eneloop%29%20%233
Nitecore%20i8%20%28eneloop%29%20%234
Nitecore%20i8%20%28eneloop%29%20%235
Nitecore%20i8%20%28eneloop%29%20%236
Nitecore%20i8%20%28eneloop%29%20%237
Nitecore%20i8%20%28eneloop%29%20%238

One slot had a temperature raise, the other terminated just before that.

Nitecore%20i8%20%28powerex%29%20%231
Nitecore%20i8%20%28eneloopPro%29%20%231

With the two high capacity cells there is a temperature raise, i.e. they are filled.

Nitecore%20i8%20%28eneloopAAA%29%20%231

The AAA cell is handled exactly like the AA cells.

Nitecore%20i8%20full%20%28eneloop%29%20%231

The full cell is detected in about 8 minutes.

Nitecore%20i8%20%288xeneloop%29

The average charge current is about the same with 8 cells.

Nitecore%20i8%2012V%20%288xeneloop%29

The charger needs abot 1.3A from a 12V supply to charge 8 NiMH.

Temp5086

M1: 36,7°C, M2: 36,8°C, M3: 35,2°C, M4: 34,8°C, M5: 64,6°C, HS1: 75,8°C

Temp5087

M1: 42,8°C, HS1: 59,5°C

PoweronNiMH

The charger is also fast to start with NiMH batteries.

Charge2NiMH

Two batteries on opposite sides will start time sharing, at the same time charging current will be doubled to maintain charging speed.

Charge4NiMH

With NiMH the current is the same independent on the number of batteries.



USB output


  • Power consumption when idle is 0.85 watt
  • Both usb output coded as usb charger (DCP)
  • Usb outputs are in parallel.
  • Batteries takes priority over usb, usb will turn off if 3 or 4 slot pairs (either of front/back) are used.


NiteCore%20i8%20top%20230V%20load%20sweep

The overload protection kick in at about 3A.

NiteCore%20i8%20bottom%20230V%20load%20sweep

On both outputs.

NiteCore%20i8%20230V%20load%20sweep

And also when running them in parallel.

NiteCore%20i8%20120V%20load%20sweep

The overload protection is slightly higher at 120VAC input.

NiteCore%20i8%20230V%20load%20test

Running the output with a 2.1A load for one hour is no problem.
The temperature photos below are taken between 30 minutes and 60 minutes into the one hour test.

Temp5094

M1: 44,1°C, M2: 43,8°C, HS1: 55,9°C

Temp5095

HS1: 58,6°C

Temp5096

HS1: 63,6°C

10ohm

Noise is 19mV rms and 124mVpp

5ohm

Noise is 19mV rms and 257mVpp

2ohm

Noise is 16mV rms and 99mVpp, all very low values.


Testing with 2830 volt and 4242 volt between mains and low volt side, did not show any safety problems.



Conclusion

With 8 slots is can charge a lot of batteries, but with LiIon it is a bit slow because the charge rate is halved when both sides of the charger is used, with NiMH is is always slow, the current is doubled when both sides are used, i.e. charge time is the same.
The charge voltage for LiIon is rather high at 4.28V (Maximum allowed is 4.25V), this means increased wear on the batteries. It will also trip the overcharge protection on some batteries, this usual reset itself when the battery is removed from the charger.
With NiMH it is better, the charger stops on voltage when the battery is just about full (a top-off charge would have been nice) and there is no trickle charge.
The usb outputs works fine and have a good coding, I just wonder why there are two connectors, the power level is only enough for one charge port.

I will call the charger acceptable.


Notes

Here is an explanation on how I did the above charge curves: How do I test a charger

My website with reviews of many chargers and batteries (More than 1000): https://lygte-info.dk/

Test/review of LiitoKala Lii-S1

$
0
0

LiitoKala Lii-S1

DSC_6378

DSC_6379DSC_6380

LiitoKala has made a couple of small usb chargers, this model adds a voltage display to the smallest model.

DSC_6372DSC_6373DSC_6374DSC_6375

The charger arrived in a nice cardboard box with specifications on it.

DSC_6376

The pack contained the charger, usb cable and a instruction sheet.

DSC_6381

The charger is powered from micro usb.

DSC_6383

The charger has a LED display and some leds together with a button for user interface.

DSC_6623

When putting a LiIon battery in the charger the 3.70V chemistry leds starts flash, presses on the button will change the selected chemistry.

DSC_6622

Holding the button down will change the current and show the new value.

DSC_6619

It is easy to see when the charger is done.

DSC_6620

No battery in charger.

DSC_6385DSC_6386

The charger uses the typical slider construction, it can handle batteries from 33mm to 70mm.

supportedBatteryTypes

supportedBatterySizesDSC_7075DSC_7076DSC_7077

DSC_7078DSC_7084DSC_7085DSC_7081DSC_7082DSC_7083

The charger can just about handle 70mm long batteries (The 21700 was very tight), inclusive flat top cells, this means most protected cells.



Measurements charger


  • LiIon and NiMH Batteries will be discharged with 0.1mA when power is off.
  • Default charger current is 0.5A
  • Voltmeter is within 0.02V, except at very low voltages.
  • Voltmeter will only update reading slowly and will never reduce the value.
  • Above 2 volt a battery is assumed to be LiIon.
  • Charger will not restart when battery voltage drops, but see below.
  • Charger will restart charging after power loss, or battery insertion.


Charging 4.20 volt LiIon

LiitoKala%20Lii-S1%201A%20%28SA18650-33%29

I wonder why the current drops from the start, maybe the charger is damaged again, the 1A reverse curve looks more normal.
The termination is a bit strange, there is some sort of trickle charge going on.

LiitoKala%20Lii-S1%200.5A%20%28SA18650-33%29

A fine CC/CV charge curve, There is also trickle charge here.

LiitoKala%20Lii-S1%201A%20%28PA18650-31%29

This older cell has more problems with termination. The current must be fairly low, because the cell voltage do not increase after the pulse.

LiitoKala%20Lii-S1%201A%20%28SA18650-26%29

There is some instability problems in the internal regulation as can be seen from 165 to 180 minutes, this is not a problem for the charging.

LiitoKala%20Lii-S1%201A%20%28BE18650-26%29

LiitoKala%20Lii-S1%200.5A%20%28AW18350-IMR%29

This very old cell drops significantly in voltage when charging terminates and this means lots of restarts.

LiitoKala%20Lii-S1%200.5A%20%28KP14500-08%29

LiitoKala%20Lii-S1%201A%20rev%20%28SA18650-33%29

The charger can work with the cell either way around in the slot, here I charged it with + away from the display.

LiitoKala%20Lii-S1%201A%200.5ohm%20%28SA18650-33%29

Adding a resistor in series with the usb power supply to simulate a long cable or weak supply did not prevent the charger from doing a good job, but it needed some more time.

Temp5099

M1: 32.8°C, M2: 37.5°C, M3: 39.5°C, HS1: 50.5°C

PoweronLiIon

With LiIon cells the charger gives the user some time to select LiIon chemistry, before it slowly ramps the current up.

CurrentChangeLiIon

The slow ramp is also used when increasing current during charge, decreasing goes fast.

TrickleChargeLiIon

The “trickle charge”, I wonder why the charger do that. The actual current is only a few mA and will not do any damage if batteries are removed in a couple of hours after it is finished.



Charging 4.35 volt LiIon

LiitoKala%20Lii-S1%201A%20%28LG18650-30%29

The 4.35 volt charge works as expected.



Charging 3.60 volt LiIon

LiitoKala%20Lii-S1%201A%20%2818650-LiFePO4%29
LiitoKala%20Lii-S1%200.5A%20%28SO14500-LiFePO%29

Both LiFePO4 cells is charged fine to 3.65 volt. Again the charger is pulsing, the actual pulse current is about 170mA for the 18650 cell, but only for a second or two. This is a sort of trickle charging.



Charging NiMH

LiitoKala%20Lii-S1%201A%20%28eneloop%29

The charger stops on voltage and will trickle charger with a low current. The termination looks to be slight premature.

LiitoKala%20Lii-S1%201A%20%28eneloopPro%29

The Pro is also terminated on voltage, here the cell has started to warm up, i.e. it is full.

LiitoKala%20Lii-S1%201A%20%28powerex%29

The powerex cell is worn down and the termination is a bit slow.

LiitoKala%20Lii-S1%200.5A%20%28eneloop%29

At 0.5A the voltage termination looks fine.

LiitoKala%20Lii-S1%200.5A%20%28eneloopAAA%29

The AAA is again slightly premature in termination.

LiitoKala%20Lii-S1%201A%20%28leise25%29

This Chinese cell is terminated perfectly on -dv/dt.

LiitoKala%20Lii-S1%201A%20full%20%28eneloop%29

With voltage termination a full cell can be detected fast.

LiitoKala%20Lii-S1%201A%20rev%20%28eneloop%29

This cell was put in the charger the other way around , this is not a problem for the charger.

Temp5111

HS1: 53.8°C, M1: 35.8°C, M2: 38.3°C, M3: 39.0°C

PoweronNiMH

The charger starts faster with NiMH, but uses a slow ramp and measuring pulses.

CurrentChangeNiMH

Current change also uses the slow ramp when increasing current, but not when decreasing current.



Conclusion

I like the idea with a voltage display on a simple charger. The multi chemistry can also be useful and the two current means more battery sizes can be charger at a good rate.
The charger specifications says it can charger from 0V, but that is not really possible with reversible batteries, there is a risk batteries are charged backwards.
NiMH is the typical voltage termination and without any top-off charge, it means slightly undercharged batteries.
The trickle charge is low enough that it will not be a problem as long as the batteries are removed within a couple of hours.

I wonder how robust the charger is, I damaged one during some detailed test and #2 may also be damage (See first curve).

I will rate the charger acceptable.



Notes

Here is an explanation on how I did the above charge curves: How do I test a charger
Read more about how I test USB power supplies/charger

My website with reviews of many chargers and batteries (More than 1000): https://lygte-info.dk/

Test/review of UltraFire H2 (HXY-H2)

$
0
0

UltraFire H2 (HXY-H2)

DSC_6912

DSC_6913DSC_6914

I got this charger as an UltraFire, but the original brand is still on the charger.

DSC_6909

The charger arrived in a brown cardboard box without any printing on it.

DSC_6911

The pack contained the charger, usb cable, car cable, but no instruction sheet.

DSC_6915

The charger is powered from mains or from 12V with a small barrel connector.

DSC_6919

The charger has a LCD display and a button for each slot. Pressing the button will show the selected current, pressing again will change selected current. Holding down the button for 10 seconds will select LiFePO4.

DSC_7090

All the segments on the display.

DSC_7095

Voltage readout during charging.

DSC_7096

Actual current. The top bar in the batteries are animated while charging.

DSC_7097

Time used.

DSC_6916

There is specifications and approval marks on the back.

DSC_6917DSC_6918

The charger uses the typical slider construction, it can handle batteries from 32mm to 71mm.

supportedBatteryTypes

supportedBatterySizesDSC_7060DSC_7061DSC_7062

DSC_7063DSC_7064DSC_7065DSC_7066DSC_7068DSC_7067

The charger can handle 70mm long batteries, inclusive flat top cells, this means most protected cells.



Measurements charger


  • LiIon and NiMH Batteries will be discharged with 0.3mA when power is off.
  • Default charger current is 0.5A
  • Below 0.2 volt the charger reports “Err”
  • Between 0.2 volt and 2 volt charger assumes battery to be NiMH
  • Above 2 volt a battery is assumed to be LiIon.
  • Voltmeter is within 0.01V
  • Voltmeter stops updating when the charging stops.
  • Charger will not restart if battery voltage drops.
  • Charger will restart charging after power loss, or battery insertion.
  • Power consumption when idle is 0.55 watt with display off.


Charging 4.20 volt LiIon


Ultrafire%20H2%201A%20%28SA18650-33%29%20%231

This looks like a good CC/CV charge curve with about 100mA termination current. The pulsing current probably means it uses simulated CC/CV charging.

Ultrafire%20H2%201A%20%28SA18650-33%29%20%232

Something went wrong here, the charger use CC and never enters the CV phase, this means the voltage goes above the allowed 4.25V, but not very much. The battery is not charged fully, but not that far from it. I did this curve twice, both looked the same.

Ultrafire%20H2%200.5A%20%28SA18650-33%29%20%232

Slot #2 did not work at 1A, how about 0.5A? It is the same, no CV phase.

Ultrafire%20H2%201A%20%28SA18650-26%29%20%231

Nice charging, the termination current is different here, because it is not used for terminating the charger.

Ultrafire%20H2%201A%20%28PA18650-31%29%20%231
Ultrafire%20H2%201A%20%28BE18650-26%29%20%231

Both these batteries are nicely charged.

Ultrafire%20H2%201A%20%28BE18650-26%29%20%232

But that was on slot #1, what about slot #2, as expected the voltage is higher (4.3V) and the final result is only 4.1V, this is the problem with using the wrong charging algorithm.

Ultrafire%20H2%200.5A%20%28SA18650-33%29%20%231

Low current works fine.

Ultrafire%20H2%200.5A%20%28AW18350-IMR%29%20%231

This old and worn down cell is nicely charged.

Ultrafire%20H2%200.5A%20%28KP14500-08%29%20%231

This cell is much easier to charge and is also handled nicely.

Ultrafire%20H2%201A%20%282xSA18650-33%29

Two cells at 1A works fine at least on slot #1.

Ultrafire%20H2%201A%2012V%20%282xSA18650-33%29

The charger uses about 0.9A from 12V for it.

Temp5177

M1: 36.7°C, M2: 37.1°C, M3: 57.6°C, M4: 44.6°C, HS1: 64.5°C
Some parts inside the charger get warm, but the batteries are fine.

Temp5178

HS1: 51.2°C

PoweronLiIon

The charger needs about 4 seconds to start.

CurrentChangeLiIon

There is no problem with changing current while charging. It requires two pressed on the button, first press will show the actual charge current, next press will change it.

ChargingLiIon

The charger measures voltage with current turned off.



Charging 3.60 volt LiIon (LiFePO4)

Selecting LiFePO4 is non-obvious without a manual. The button must be held down for 10 seconds!

Ultrafire%20H2%200.5A%20%28SO14500-LiFePO4%29%20%231

Ultrafire%20H2%201A%20%2818650-LiFePO4%29%20%231

Charging LiFePO4 works fine (On slot #1, I did not try #2), they are charged to 3.65V



Charging NiMH

Ultrafire%20H2%201A%20%28eneloop%29%20%231

The NiMH charging stops a slightly premature, but not much, it looks loke the temperature is just about to raise.

Ultrafire%20H2%201A%20%28eneloop%29%20%232

On the second channel it is also a bit premature.

Ultrafire%20H2%201A%20%28eneloopPro%29%20%231

With the eneloopPro the charger stops way before the cell is charged.

Ultrafire%20H2%201A%20%28powerex%29%20%231

This old cell is handled correctly, it stops when the cell heats up.

Ultrafire%20H2%201A%20%28Leise25%29%20%231

This is a cheap Chinese cell and is charged nicely.

Ultrafire%20H2%200.5A%20%28eneloop%29%20%231

Using low charge current do not really work with this cell, the charger stops way to early.

Ultrafire%20H2%200.5A%20%28eneloopAAA%29%20%231

It works better with the AAA, but it stops too early again.

Ultrafire%20H2%201A%20full%20%28eneloop%29%20%231

There is no problem stopping with a full cell.

Ultrafire%20H2%201A%20%282xeneloop%29

Two cells are also nearly charged.

Ultrafire%20H2%201A%2012V%20%282xeneloop%29

It requires about 0.5A from 12V to charge two NiMH cells.

Temp5191

M1: 42.6°C, M2: 42.8°C, M3: 57.4°C, HS1: 89.6°C

PoweronNiMH

The charger needs about 4 seconds to start.

CurrentChangeNiMH

There is no problem with changing current while charging. It requires two pressed on the button, first press will show the actual charge current, next press will change it.

ChargingNiMH

As usual for NiMH the charger measured voltage with current turned off and at a much faster pace than it do for LiIon.



Conclusion

The charger is fairly easy to use (LiFePO4 is a bit tricky to select) with a good display and has support for a large selection of battery sizes and chemistries.
Slot #1 works fairly well for LiIon, but slot #2 do not. This is the first time I have seen a charger with different charge algorithms in the two slots and hopefully also the last time!
NiMH do not always charge fully.

I will only rate it as useable (Two different LiIon charge algorithms is not acceptable).



Notes

The charger was supplied by Fasttech for review.

Here is an explanation on how I did the above charge curves: How do I test a charger
Read more about how I test USB power supplies/charger

My website with reviews of many chargers and batteries (More than 1000): https://lygte-info.dk/

Test/review of Charger Brillipower BIC-2

$
0
0

Charger Brillipower BIC-2

DSC_9245

DSC_9246DSC_9247

This is a simple charger that can handle NiMH and LiIon cells and has one charge current.

DSC_9211DSC_9212DSC_9213DSC_9214

The charger comes in a cardboard box with some information on the back.

DSC_9242

The pack contained the charger, a mains cable and a instruction sheet.

DSC_9249

The charger has mains input and 12V DC input.

DSC_9250

The user interface is 3 blue leds for each slot, they are animated while charging and all will be steady on when the battery is full.

DSC_9248

The charger is supposed to support both 4.2V and 4.35V cells, but there is no way to select charge voltage.

DSC_9251DSC_9252

The charger uses the classical slider construction, it will handle from 34mm to 70.5mm long batteries. This means it will handle nearly all the long batteries.

supportedBatteryTypes

supportedBatterySizesDSC_9776DSC_9777DSC_9778

DSC_9779DSC_9780DSC_9781DSC_9782DSC_9783DSC_9784DSC_9785


The charge current is too high for smaller cells.



Measurements on charger


  • LiIon batteries will be discharged with 1.5mA when power is off.
  • LiIon batteries will be charged with 0.5mA when power is on.
  • NiMH batteries will be discharged with 0.5mA when power is off.
  • Below 0.3 volt the charger will charge with lower current trying to start battery and flash all the blue leds.
  • Below 1.5 volt the charger assumens NiMH batteries.
  • Between 1.5 volt and 2.2 volt the leds are off and the charger is not charging.
  • At 2.2 volt and above the charger assumes LiIon.
  • Power consumption when idle is 0.3 watt.
  • Charger will not restart if battery voltage drops.
  • Charger will restart on battery insertion and power cycling.


Charging LiIon

Brillipower%20BIC-2%20%28SA18650-33%29%20%231

The charge is a CC/CV curve with termination around 100mA

Brillipower%20BIC-2%20%28SA18650-33%29%20%232

It is the same on the second channel.

Brillipower%20BIC-2%20%28SA18650-26%29%20%231
Brillipower%20BIC-2%20%28PA18650-31%29%20%231

Other capacities is handled fine.

Brillipower%20BIC-2%20%28BE18650-26%29%20%231

Even a old cell with fairly high internal resistance.

BrilliPower%20BIC-2%20%28AW18350-IMR%29%20%231
BrilliPower%20BIC-2%20%28KP14500-08%29%20%231

Small cells are charged with too high current, but the charger do fill them.

Brillipower%20BIC-2%20%282xSA18650-33%29

With two cells the average current is halved, at 500 minutes cell #2 is full and cell #1 get the full current.

Brillipower%20BIC-2%2012V%20%282xSA1865-33%29

The charger needs about 600mA from an external 12V power supply.

Temp4202

M1: 36,6°C, M2: 38,7°C, M3: 51,5°C, M4: 53,0°C, HS1: 62,3°C

PowerOnLiIon

The charger needs about 2 seconds to start.

ChargingLiIon

It has two types of pauses, some fairly short and some longer about every 20 seconds.

ChargingLiIon2

The short pauses is used for timesharing, i.e. switching the current to the other cell when there are two cells.




Charging NiMH

Brillipower%20BIC-2%20%28eneloop%29%20%231

This is a voltage termination, but without top-off charge, there is a obvious temperature raise, i.e. the cell is full.

Brillipower%20BIC-2%20%28eneloop%29%20%232

This time it uses a -dv/dt termination, but it charges a bit more later on.

Brillipower%20BIC-2%20%28eneloopPro%29%20%231

A voltage termination.

Brillipower%20BIC-2%20%28eneloopXX%29%20%231

This old cell do not really work anymore. The charger did put some energy into it, before it terminated the charge.

Brillipower%20BIC-2%20%28powerex%29%20%231

On this cell a -dv/dt termination is used.

Brillipower%20BIC-2%20%28eneloopAAA%29%20%231

The charger current is on the high side for AAA cells, this makes the charging fast.

Brillipower%20BIC-2%20full%20%28eneloop%29%20%231

A full cell is detected in about 5 minutes.

Brillipower%20BIC-2%20%282xeneloop%29

With two cells the current is reduced and that means problems with termination. The charger could have terminated 30 minutes earlier.

Brillipower%20BIC-2%2012V%20%282xeneloop%29

This time the termination time it is slightly better. The charger need about 0.3A when powered from 12V and charging NiMH.

Temp4208

M1: 38,6°C, M2: 41,0°C, M3: 47,3°C, M4: 47,3°C, HS1: 58,5°C

PowerOnNiMH

About 2.5 seconds to start charging.

ChargingNiMH

With NiMH it has the same type of pauses as with LiIon

ChargingNiMH2

And it also use timesharing when charging two cells.


Testing the charger with 2830 volt and 4242 volt between mains and low volt side, did not show any safety problems.



Conclusion

This is a simple charger with a single charger current that can be either used on one cell or time shared between two cells. The current is too high for small cells. The promised 4.35V charging is missing.
Due to the single current the charger is not good at smaller cells.
The charger do a fairly good charge.



Notes

Here is an explanation on how I did the above charge curves: How do I test a charger
Charge selection table

My website with reviews of many chargers and batteries (More than 1000): https://lygte-info.dk/

Test/review of Vapex VTE8000 8xNiMH charger

$
0
0

Vapex VTE8000 8xNiMH charger

DSC_3785

DSC_3787DSC_3788

This multi charger can be used for AA and AAA and handle up to 8 at a time. It can also be used as a usb charger.

DSC_3746DSC_3747DSC_3784

I got the charger in a blister pack. The pack has some specifications on it.

DSC_3786

The pack contained the charger and a universal power supply with multiple plugs.

DSC_9829

The power connector is placed on the side of the charger and will accept from 10V to 18V input.

DSC_3790

The user interface is a LCD display with 8 batteries on it, it has a blue background light.

DSC_3791DSC_3792DSC_3793

The connection are the typical two level slots.

supportedBatteryTypes

supportedBatterySizes




Measurements charger


  • When not powered it will discharge the battery with about 0.6mA
  • Charge will restart charging after power loss, or battery insertion.
  • Power consumption when idle is 1.4 watt


Vapex%20VTE8000%20%28eneloop%29%20%231

Fairly high charge current and voltage termination. The charger uses trickle charge.

Vapex%20VTE8000%20%28eneloop%29%20%232
Vapex%20VTE8000%20%28eneloop%29%20%233
Vapex%20VTE8000%20%28eneloop%29%20%234
Vapex%20VTE8000%20%28eneloop%29%20%235
Vapex%20VTE8000%20%28eneloop%29%20%236
Vapex%20VTE8000%20%28eneloop%29%20%237
Vapex%20VTE8000%20%28eneloop%29%20%238

All channels looks the same.


Vapex%20VTE8000%20%28eneloopPro%29%20%231
Vapex%20VTE8000%20%28powerex%29%20%231

These two high capacity cells are charged the same way.

Vapex%20VTE8000%20%28eneloopXX%29%20%231

This cell is rather old with high internal resistance and the charger cannot handle it.

Vapex%20VTE8000%20%28eneloopAAA%29%20%231

The AAA is is handled like the other cells, the charge current is very high for a single AAA cell.

Vapex%20VTE8000%20full%20%28eneloop%29%20%231

The charger is very very fast to detect a full cell.

Vapex%20VTE8000%20%282xeneloop%29

With two cells the average current is 1/2 of one cell besides each other.

Vapex%20VTE8000%20%284xeneloop%29

And with four cells it is 1/4 of one cell besides each other.

Vapex%20VTE8000%20%288xeneloop%29

With eight cells the current is the same because I am using the other side of the charger.

Temp3039

M1: 36,1°C, M2: 35,9°C, M3: 35,8°C, M4: 35,6°C, M5: 37,1°C, M6: 38,6°C, M7: 41,2°C, M8: 42,7°C, HS1: 53,6°C
It is easy to see where the power handling in the charger is placed.

Poweron

The charger is fairly fast to initialize.

Charge2

The charger has two 2A charging circuit, one for each side and will time share them between the present batteries, the above chart is with two batteries.

Charge4

Here the time sharing for 4 batteries is shown.


Testing the transformer with 2830 volt and 4242 volt between mains and low volt side, did not show any safety problems.




Conclusion

The charger has two charge circuits, each time sharing on four slots. Using voltage termination without top-off charge means that the batteries will be charged slightly below full charge. The high charge current (2A) is acceptable for AA batteries, but problematic for AAA batteries or older AA batteries.

I will rate the charger acceptable.



Notes

Here is an explanation on how I did the above charge curves: How do I test a charger

My website with reviews of many chargers and batteries (More than 1000): https://lygte-info.dk/

Test/review of GP Recyko+ Pro U411

$
0
0

GP Recyko+ Pro U411

DSC_8904

DSC_8905DSC_8906

GP has a line of both chargers and batteries, this charger includes a set of NiMH batteries and as can be seen on the label GP means the charger is free. This is reflected in the naming of the pack: it is only named for the batteries.
The charger can charge two or four AA/AAA batteries at a time and is usb powered.

DSC_8864DSC_8866DSC_8865DSC_8867

I got the charger in a partial clear plastic pack.

DSC_8901

The pack contains the charger, a usb cable, 4 2000mAh pre-charged NiMH AA batteries and a instruction sheet. The batteries will be covered in their own review.

DSC_8907

The charger has a micro usb connector for power input.

DSC_8740

There are two led indicator lamps, flashing when charging and steady when not.

DSC_8908

The charger is rated for 1A input, this is a bit high for a total charge current of 0.6A. Notice the hole in the bottom, this makes it easy to remove the batteries.

DSC_8909DSC_8910DSC_8911

The charger has the typical two level slots used for AA/AAA batteres.


supportedBatteryTypes

supportedBatterySizes



Measurements


  • Slot #1 & #2 is in series.
  • Slot #3 & #4 is in series.
  • Power consumption when idle is 1.3mA from usb
  • When not powered it will not discharge batteries.
  • Trickle charger on NiMH is about 50mA
  • Will charge from 0 volt with nearly 1A.
  • Charge will restart charging after power loss, or battery insertion.


GP%20ReCyklo%2B%20%282xeneloop%29%2012

The charger will charge for nearly 8 hours and then switch to 50mA tricke charge, charge current will vary with battery voltage.


GP%20ReCyklo%2B%20%282xeneloop%29%2034

The two other slots looks the same.

GP%20ReCyklo%2B%20%282xeneloopPro%29%2012

When using high capacity batteries the fixed charge time is not enough to fill the batteries.

GP%20ReCyklo%2B%20%282xeneloopXX%29%2012

This charger do not care about the condition of the batteries, they call get the same charge.

GP%20ReCyklo%2B%20%282xpowerex%29%2012

These batteries have to much capacity to be filled.

GP%20ReCyklo%2B%20%282xeneloopAAA%29%2012

An AAA cell has less capacity, the charger handles that by lower charge current and using the same charge time.
These batteries are just about filled.

GP%20ReCyklo%2B%20full%20%282xeneloop%29%2012

Putting full batteries in the charger is a bad idea, they get another full charge.

GP%20ReCyklo%2B%20%284xeneloop%29

2 or 4 batteries do not matter for charge speed or algorithm.

GP%20ReCyklo%2B%20%284xeneloop%29a

Power consumption is about 0.7A, not the rated 1A, but this will depend on battery voltage.

Temp4160

M1: 37,4°C, M2: 37,6°C, M3: 37,4°C, M4: 37,1°C, HS1: 43,2°C

Temp4171

M1: 46,4°C, M2: 49,6°C, M3: 49,7°C, M4: 46,2°C, HS1: 52,3°C
When batteries are full the temperature will raise and stay that way for some time while waiting for the timer termination.

Poweron

The charger is fairly fast to start. The there is only one charge circuit it will time share between the two sets (1+2 and 3+4).


Conclusion

This is a very simple charger with timer based control, it works fine for empty 2000mAh AA cells or empty 900mA AAA cells, but not for anything else.

I will call the charger usable.


Notes

Here is an explanation on how I did the above charge curves: How do I test a charger

My website with reviews of many chargers and batteries (More than 1000): https://lygte-info.dk/


[Review]Folomov A4 Charger

$
0
0

I previously have tested the Folomov EDC C4 flashlight and thought it was solid. Folomov also makes chargers and here is their largest, fastest charging model, the Folomov A4, that’s capable of a combined 8A across the slots with a max per slot of 3A.

Full Image Gallery:https://imgur.com/a/ooUgsp4
*YouTube Version of this Review: *

Build Quality Build quality seems pretty solid no major complaints. It’s injection molded ABS plastic. It’s sturdy and seams fit together nicely. On the back is the 12V input connector. It’s a little loose in the connection and with the included power supply doesn’t fit quite as far in as I would like. On the bottom there are what look to be vent holes but they are purely cosmetic as they are not cut through to allow air flow nor is there a fan.

I did have one issue with one of the spring loaded slots with the spring coming disconnected. I was able to easily disassemble and reattach it. The spring slots are a little rough when you pull them back, not as smooth as my Xtar VC4 or Nitecore chargers. That said they work well on a wide variety of cells, anything I tried including a 20700.




The display is inverse of many LCD panels. It’s background is black and the display characters are white. It’s easy to read and decent sized. I like that each cell gets it’s own dedicated spot on the display and you get the voltage all the time.

One thing I wish it did have was little rubber feet. I like to charge on a piece of granite tile and all my other chargers have rubber feet that keeps them from sliding around the table when inserting cells, the Folomov A4 doesn’t so you need to hold onto it with one hand while installing a cell with the other.

Display & UI
When you plug in the charger if there isn’t a cell in the slot you get a “null” message. Upon putting in a cell it will default to 250ma charging which is slow. You just have to press the button once and it goes to 500ma, press again for 1000ma, again for 2000ma, and again for 3000mah if available. The UI here is a little slow, you can’t double click to jump up in rates faster you have to press and wait. It’s not that big of deal for me but something to know about. Each bay is independent as well.

Instead of working from a bank of 8A and the charger deducting amounts as you insert cells, this charger let’s you set each bay as high as you want and takes power from other cells. For example say I charge Bay 1 at 3A, Bay 2 at 3A, it would let me insert a cell into Bay 3 and set it to 3A but since that’s over 8A total it would reduce Bay 1 to 2A without letting you know.

The charger will then analyze the cell and during this analysis phase the capacity in percentage you get may not be true. This is why I prefer voltage to look at. The same holds true for when it’s full. It will sit for quite a while at 98-99% at 4.2V on a lithium ion battery before ticking over to 100%. Not entirely sure why this is. It includes overvoltage protection too, a nice bit of safety. The charger also has 0V activation which I did not test.

How does it handle different sized cells
The A4 handles a wide variety of sizes of cells with ease. I tried everything from normal NiHM AAA, AA cells, to 16340, flat top 18350, and all the different types of 18650’s that I have including protected, unprotected, flat tops and button tops. I also tried a button top protected 26650 without an issue. Spacing on the A4 is large between bays so it can accept 4× 26650 at once which is fantastic as many 4 bay chargers can only accept two at a time.

The AC/DC adapter is a separate piece, it looks like a laptop style power supply. It’s fairly large and has long cables. It’s rated for 110-240V input power. Since this does look like a laptop power supply and it is not branded as Folomov, my advice would be to label the charger so you don’t get it mixed up with something else you may have.

Conclusion
This is a fairly simple charger but is fast for both Li-Ion and Nimh batteries. I would rate it as a good charger but not the best charger. It’s UI is a bit slow when changing charging rates. It seems to hit a wall at 98% with the last 2 percent taking longer than it feels like it should. It has a large external power supply but lots of cord length. The connector into the charger is looser then I would like. However these slight negatives are outweighed by the nice white text, black background LCD Screen, and total of 8A charge capacity, with a maximum of 3A per slot upto 8A total. I like how it can charge a wide selection of sizes of batteries and chemistries it can take. This is a safe charger that does the job well. I can recommend it as a good value fast charger.

Pick it up on Amazon (Referral) if you are interested.

Test/review of Charger TrustFire TR-009

$
0
0

Charger TrustFire TR-009

DSC_4523

DSC_4524DSC_4525

This charger can charge up to 4 LiIon and NiMH batteries at a time. Usual TrustFire products do not inspire much trust, lets see how this one does.

DSC_4517DSC_4519DSC_4518DSC_4520

The charger comes in a retail box. There is some specification on the box.

DSC_4521

The pack contained the charger, a mains led, a instruction sheet, a warrenty card and a QC note.

DSC_4526

The power input is a DC barrel input.

DSC_4527

The charger has one usb output, it can use from 1 to 4 cells to power it.

DSC_4530DSC_4528

The user interface is fairly limited. It contains 4 red/green leds, red while charging, green at all other times, except when usb output is on. Then the usb output has its own green led that will be on when it is active.
To change between charging and usb output a switch is used (C=Charge, O=usb output).

DSC_4531DSC_4532

The battery slot are the slider construction, but with plastic sliders. It is very smooth and has a good grip on batteries with large diameter, but smaller batteries (Like AA) can be problematic to center on the slider.
It handles batteries form 31 to 71.5mm.


supportedBatteryTypes

supportedBatterySizesDSC_6311DSC_6312DSC_6313

DSC_6314DSC_6315DSC_6316DSC_6317

DSC_6318DSC_6319DSC_6320

The current is a bit high for 16340 and 14500 LiIon batteries.



Measurements


  • Power consumption when idle is 0.8 watt, power supply uses 0.5 watt of that.
  • Slot 1+3 are working together, i.e. use both slots and the current will drop.
  • Slot 2+4 are working together, i.e. use both slots and the current will drop.
  • If on slot in a pair finish first, the other will get the full current.
  • Below 0.8V the charger will charge with 0.5mA
  • Between 0.8V and 1.5V the charger will use NiMH charging.
  • Between 1.5 and 2.5 volt the charger will charge with 0.25mA
  • Above 2.5V the charger will use LiIon charging.
  • Will discharge NiMH with 0.1mA when power is off
  • Will discharge LiIon with 0.4mA when power is off
  • Will charge LiIon with 0.1mA when power is on
  • If the battery voltage drops below 4.23V the charger will restart.
  • Charge will restart charging after power loss, or battery insertion.


Charging LiIon

Trustfire%20TR-009%20(PA18650-31)%20%231

The charging looks like a simulated CC/CV charge, the charger go to the upper voltage limit. Termination is at about 150mA

Trustfire%20TR-009%20(PA18650-31)%20%232
Trustfire%20TR-009%20(PA18650-31)%20%233
Trustfire%20TR-009%20(PA18650-31)%20%234

The other slots looks the same.

Trustfire%20TR-009%20(SA18650-26)%20%231

No problems here.

Trustfire%20TR-009%20(PA18650-34)%20%231

This also looks fine.

Trustfire%20TR-009%20(BE18650-26)%20%231

With a older cell the charge voltage goes above the 4.25V limit.

Trustfire%20TR-009%20(AW18350-IMR)%20%231

The same with this cell.

Trustfire%20TR-009%20(4xPA18650-31)

With 4 cells the charge speed is reduced.

Trustfire%20TR-009%2012V%20(4xPA18650-31)

If using an external 12V supply it needs about 2.2A.

Temp3575

M1: 40,1°C, M2: 42,6°C, M3: 43,4°C, M4: 41,4°C, M5: 49,2°C, HS1: 64,5°C




StartupLiIon

The charger starts immediately and measures the voltage with current off.

Charge4LiIon

With 4 cells the current is reduced, there is not time sharing between slots.




Charging NiMH

Trustfire%20TR-009%20(eneloop)%20%231

It looks like the charger stops on voltage before the cells are full.

Trustfire%20TR-009%20(eneloop)%20%232
Trustfire%20TR-009%20(eneloop)%20%233
Trustfire%20TR-009%20(eneloop)%20%234

Same with the other slots.

Trustfire%20TR-009%20(eneloopXX)%20%231
Trustfire%20TR-009%20(eneloopPro)%20%231
Trustfire%20TR-009%20(powerex)%20%231

The high capacity cells has the same problem.

Trustfire%20TR-009%20(eneloopAAA)%20%231

And also the AAA cell.

Trustfire%20TR-009%20(4xeneloop)

Exactly same problem with 4 cells.

TrustFire%20TR-009%2012V%20%284xeneloop%29

Maximum current from 12V is about 0.6A.

Temp3585

M1: 39,6°C, M2: 42,3°C, M3: 43,0°C, M4: 40,8°C, M5: 55,9°C, M6: 50,2°C, HS1: 69,9°C



StartupNiMH

The charger starts immediately and measures the voltage with current off.

Charge4NiMH





Usb output


  • Usb coding is unknown (It is 2.4V on both data pins).
  • Usb output can only be supplied from batteries, not from mains.
  • Will draw 0.4mA from battery with usb out turned off.
  • Will draw 20mA from battery with usb out turned on.


TrustFire%20TR-009%20%28PA18650-31%29%20%231%20load%20sweep

With a single 18650 the usb output can deliver about 0.9A

TrustFire%20TR-009%20%284xPA18650-31%29%20load%20sweep

Adding more batteries do not improve the output current.

TrustFire%20TR-009%20usb%20out%2010ohm%20%28PA18650-31%29%20%231

A single battery only gives about 20 minutes power at 0.5A, this is not very good.

TrustFire%20TR-009%20usb%20out%2010ohm%20%284xPA18650-31%29

Using four cells is much better, there the output is stable for about 13 hours.

TrustFire%20TR-009%20usb%20out%205ohm%20%28PA18650-31%29%20%231

Using a 5 ohm resistor means 1A at 5 volt, i.e. slightly above the current limit. It cannot deliver anything useful on a single 18650 battery.

TrustFire%20TR-009%20usb%20out%205ohm%20%284xPA18650-31%29

With four batteries it can keep the voltage up to nearly 5 volt for more than 5 hours.

10ohm

Noise is 134mV rms and 406mVpp.

5ohm

Noise is 207mV rms and 590mVpp, this is rather high. This is not really surprising because I am above the current limit.

Testing with 2830 volt and 4242 volt between mains and low volt side, did not show any safety problems.



Conclusion

On LiIon this charger is good enough, but NiMH is not charged fully, a top-off charge would have fixed that.
The usb output is fairly low current and needs more than one battery to work, the coding and the noise is not very good.

All in all I will call it an acceptable charger.




Notes

Here is an explanation on how I did the above charge curves: How do I test a charger
Charge selection table

My website with reviews of many chargers and batteries (More than 1000): https://lygte-info.dk/

Test/review of Charger NicJoy A03 Dual

$
0
0

Charger NicJoy A03 Dual

DSC_8163

DSC_8164DSC_8165

The charger model has been on the marked for some time and is sold with many different names on it. I have checked it before, but was asked to do another check.

DSC_8156DSC_8157
DSC_8158

It arrived in a small white box

DSC_8159

It did include a usb cable and an instruction sheet (in Chinese) in addition to the charger.

DSC_8167

The charger has a micro usb input and a full size usb output for the power bank function.
The charger needs a 2A usb power supply/charger to work at full speed.

DSC_8171

The user interface is a couple of leds and a single button.
A fast press on the button will select battery type, when a battery has just been put into a slot.
A long press (2 seconds) will change current at any time.

DSC_8716

There is 4 blue leds for each slot, they are used to show charge state and when selecting battery type. Two red leds used to show selected current.

DSC_8717

One 3.7V LiIon (Charge to 4.2V) and one NiMH battery in the charger, ready to charge with 0.5A

DSC_8168DSC_8169

The slots uses the classical slider construction and it works fine.
The slots can work from 33mm to 70mm. This means that very long protected 18650/26650 batteries will not fit in the slots.

supportedBatteryTypes

supportedBatterySizesDSC_8669DSC_8670DSC_8671

DSC_8672DSC_8673DSC_8674DSC_8675DSC_8676DSC_8677

The charger has some trouble with 70mm long batteries, but can handle flat top cells.



Measurements


  • When not connected to power it will discharges with less than 0.1mA.
  • On the power bank slot it will discharge with about 0.2mA (45mA while indicating capacity).
  • When power is connected with a full battery, the charger will charge with 0.6mA
  • Below 0.1V the charger will not detect a battery, but will charger with about 3mA
  • Between 0.2A and 1.5V the charger assumes NiMH
  • Between 1.6V and 2,1V the charger will not recognize a battery, but charges with about 2mA
  • Above 2.2V the charger assumes LiIon
  • Charger will not restart when voltage drops.
  • It will restart charging on reinsertion of the battery or power cycling.
  • Usb input power consumptions when idle without batteries is 34mA

Charge LiIon 3.7V setting (4.2V charge voltage)

NicJoy%20A03%201A%20%28SA18650-33%29%20%231

This is a fairly good CC/CV charge curve with termination a bit above 100mA. The charge voltage is at the low end of the allowed tolerances.

NicJoy%20A03%201A%20%28PA18650-31%29%20%231
NicJoy%20A03%201A%20%28SA18650-26%29%20%231
NicJoy%20A03%201A%20%28BE18650-26%29%20%231

There is not much to say about the other 3 cells, they are charged correctly.

NicJoy%20A03%200.5A%20%28SA18650-33%29%20%231%20

When selecting a lower charge current the termination current stays the same.

NicJoy%20A03%200.5A%20%28AW18350-IMR%29%20%231

The termination current is a bit high for this very old and worn cell.

NicJoy%20A03%200.5A%20%28KP14500-08%29%20%231

This cell is charged fine, but the final is a bit low.

NicJoy%20A03%201A%20%282xSA18650-33%29

Charging two cells at a time works fine, the higher current draw on usb means the end of CC starts a bit earlier.

NicJoy%20A03%201A%200.5ohm%20%282xSA18650-33%29

Simulating a weak power supply by adding 0.5ohm in series with it slowed down the charging considerable, but did not prevent the charger from doing a good job.

Temp5268

M1: 34.4°C, M2: 34.2°C, M3: 39.3°C, HS1: 46.7°C

Temp5269

M1: 40.4°C, M2: 40.6°C, HS1: 48.4°C

PoweronLiIon

The charger need some time to start, most of the time is used to wait the user to select another battery type.

CurrentChangeLiIon

When changing current the charger always start from a low current and slow increase it to the selected level.



Charge LiIon 3.8V setting (4.35V charge voltage)

NicJoy%20A03%201A%20%28LG18650-30%29%20%231

No surprise with the 4.35V charge, it looks fine.



Charge LiFe 3.2V setting (3.6V charge voltage)

NicJoy%20A03%200.5A%20%28SO14500-LiFePO4%29%20%231

NicJoy%20A03%201A%20%2818650-LiFePO4%29%20%231

The two LiFePO4 charges also looks fine.



Charge NiMH 1.2V

NicJoy%20A03%201A%20%28eneloop%29%20%231

The NiMH charging terminates on voltage and do not use top-off or trickle charge. This means the cell will be slightly below a full charge.

NicJoy%20A03%201A%20%28eneloop%29%20%232

The other slot works the same way.

NicJoy%20A03%201A%20%28eneloopPro%29%20%231

And the eneloop Pro is handled the same way.

NicJoy%20A03%201A%20%28leise25%29%20%231

But thic Chinese cell is terminated on -dv/dt and is fully charged.

NicJoy%20A03%201A%20full%20%28eneloop%29%20%231

A full cell is detected fairly fast when terminating on voltage.

NicJoy%20A03%201A%20%282xeneloop%29

Due to the pulsing the input current is covering the charge current curve, but it can be seen that the input current is around 1200mA when charging NiMH.

NicJoy%20A03%201A%20%282xeneloop%29a

Same curve as above with the input current removed.

Temp5276

M1: 38.8°C, M2: 38.7°C, M3: 41.3°C, HS1: 50.8°C

Temp5277

M1: 42.4°C, HS1: 60.7°C

PoweronNiMH

NiMH needs the same time to start as LiIon, but it is not possible to select battery type.

CurrentChangeNiMH

With NiMH the current change is more abrupt.



Usb output


  • Usb output is coded as Apple 1A
  • Usb output will turn off after 10 seconds with less than 45mA load.
  • Usb output will turn off when the charger is powered.
  • On the power bank slot it will discharge with about 0.2mA (45mA while indicating capacity).


NicJoy%20A03%20Dual%20load%20sweep

The charger can deliver a bit above 1A with a full battery.

NicJoy%20A03%20Dual%20usb%20out%2010ohm%20%28SA18650-33%29

With 0.5A load the output looks nice and stable and it turns off when battery voltage is down to 3 volt.

NicJoy%20A03%20Dual%20usb%20out%205ohm%20%28SA18650-33%29

But at 1A load the usb output do not really work, the converter cannot handle a partically discharged battery.

10ohm

The noise is 57mV rms and 476mVpp.

5ohm

The noise is 91V rms and 790mVpp, this noise is a bit on the high side.



Conclusion

This charger is good at LiIon, fairly good at NiMH and the possibility to select multiple LiIon voltage makes it very versatile.

The power bank function is not very good, it uses an old coding and cannot deliver full current with a partial discharged battery, in addition to this the noise is very bad.

I.e. it is a good charger, but do not buy it for the power bank function.



Notes

The charger was supplied by gearbest for review.

Here is an explanation on how I did the above charge curves: How do I test a charger

My website with reviews of many chargers and batteries (More than 1000): https://lygte-info.dk/

[Review] Folomov A4 Charger

$
0
0

Folomov A4

MSRP: $35 - $40

Manufacturer page: http://www.folomov.com/en/content/?125.html

Store link: https://www.amazon.com/Folomov-A4-Charger-Charging-Current/dp/B07BQC3KKH

I was sent this charger to review free of charge but, as always, I've tried to be as unbiased as possible.


TL;DR

The Folomov A4 is a very fast 4 bay charger. It's capable of charging four cells at 2A each simultaneously. It can charge Li-ion, LiFePO4, NIMH, and NiCad cells. Besides overcharging Li-ion cells by 0.04V, it's great!



Album link: https://imgur.com/a/N0Jbk6G

Packaging

The Folomov A4 comes in a black and orange cardboard box. A photo of the charger is on the front, and detailed info about the charger is on the back. This box is good enough to be put on a shelf.

Contents

The box contains:

  • A Folomov A4 charger
  • An adapter
  • A cable for the adapter
  • A manual

 

Manual

 

Build

The Folomov A4 is a 4 bay charger with pretty typical construction. It's made of black ABS plastic and has 4 bays consisting of fixed positive contacts and sliders for the negative contacts. The sliders were a bit sticky on mine. They weren't bad, but they were pretty hard to move compared to the sliders on my XTAR chargers. A bit of lube on rails fixed that.

 

A common problem that I've run into with chargers like this that can charge any battery size is that sometimes they won't reliably make contact with AAAs or flat top cells. The A4 doesn't seem to have that problem.
There are fins on the sides of the charger by the screen. These look like heat fins, but I'm not sure how well they'd actually dissapate heat. Folomov chose a barrel plug as the connection type for the power cable. That's a good decision. In my experience barrel plugs make good connections, and they're robust. Not to mention that this lets Folomov use whatever voltage and current they want rather than having to use a 5V USB connection. The screen is a backlit LCD, with a black background and white images. This makes the information easy to read without putting out a blinding amount of light when in a dark room.

 


On the bottom of the charger, there's a table of recommended charging currents and a list of supported sizes and chemistries. The charging current table isn't quite correct, as discussed in the performance section, but the other information is correct, barring one typo. It says that the A4 can charge "163401735517500" cells (bonus points to anyone who can tell me what that cell would look like). I think that was supposed to say "16340 17355 (I don't think that's a real size) 17500".

 


Inside the charger, there are two main PCBs: the one for the screen, and the one for the charging.

There are 4 sections on this PCB that all have the same components, and a bit in the middle with a bunch of resistors, capacitors, and an IC.

I'm not HKJ, so I can't really tell you what's going on electrically. I also don't have a digital microscope, or a camera that's good at macro photography, so you can't really make out the chips. But I do have a great pair of eyes, so I've written down all of numbers on all of the important looking components. Here are the important looking bits:

  • nuvoTon N77E003AT20: A microcontroller. The brain of the charger, as I understand it.
  • U34 GP 731: I can't find *any* info on this one.
  • DTU 15P03 DH25: I was only able to find one page on this. I'm not sure if it's relevant, or what it says. If anyone can read Chinese, go for it. This is "a CC/CV buck converter for the microcontroller, stepping down 36V to lower voltages from 3V to 5V." Thanks /u/BlueSwordM!
  • DTM9926: This is a dual channel MOSFET.

If anyone needs more info values or model numbers let me know.

UI

When you first put a cell in that slot's screen flashes. During this time you can single press that slot's button to change the charge current. If it's a LiFePO4 cell, you'll need to press and hold the button until you see the LiFePO4 indicator turn on. While the cells are charging, the voltage is displayed by default. Single pressing the button shows the charging current, and double pressing lets you adjust the charge current and chemistry settings, like when the screen flashes when you first put a cell in.

 

When the cell is done charging, that slot says 100%, and the charging indicator stops moving.

This UI is great. It's not difficult to understand, and the screen shows everything that's going on. The only improvement I can think of is to format the manual better. The thing's a nightmare to read.

 

Performance

The A4 can charge cells at a maximum of 8A total, but only with two configurations. You can do 3A on the sides and 2A in one of the center slots, or 2A on all slots. If there is a cell in all 4 slots, the max current for any slot is limited to 2A. Because this has 4 electrically separate slots, you can charge multiple chemistries at once.


The A4 performs pretty well. It's very fast, obviously, and it's pretty versatile. It can handle cells up to 71mm long. The ability to charge 4 cells at high currents is fantastic. Mine overcharges li-ion cells a little bit to 4.24V (which is within the 1% tolerance mentioned on the back). Someone can correct me if I'm wrong, but I don't think this does any significant damage to the cells. The termination voltage for NiMH cells is 1.45V.
On the bottom of the charger, there's a little table that tells you at what currents you should charge things. It's not quite right. It doesn't factor in what sort of cell you're charging, or how high drain the cells are. For instance, it says that you're fine charging a 3000mAh cell at 3A. This is probably fine for Sony VTC6s, but not for Panasonic NCR18650Bs. I'd just ignore the chart.
Charging fast is great, but I also love how that A4 is capable of charging cells slowly too. The 250mA setting is great for 10440s.

Power Source

The Folomov is a fast 4 bay charger, so USB isn't enough. It gets its power from an adapter that plugs into mains and puts out 12V at a maximum of 8A.

Abuse Testing

The manual says the A4 has reverse polarity protection, as it should, but I decided to test a couple other things as well. First I tested the RPP. It worked fine on all four ports, displaying "Er" when the cell was in backwards. Next I tested shorting the contacts out. This also displayed "Er". Putting too much voltage (6V in this case) across the contacts didn't do anything, not even display an "Er".

Edit: It's been brought to my attention that putting two CR123As in a charger in series was stupid and dangerous. To that I say, 'yeah probably'.


Bottom line:


Pros

  • Relatively cheap
  • Very fast
  • Lots of charge current options
  • Protection against user error

Cons

  • Overcharges li-ion cells ever so slightly
  • Inaccurate chart on the bottom
  • Sliders need lubed

 

Thanks for reading my review! If you have any questions about this charger, I'd be more than happy to answer them.

Reviewer for ThorFire, Olight, Sofirn, and Folomov.

I’m much more active on /r/flashlight.

Xtar PB2 Charger & power bank

$
0
0

Xtar PB2 Charger & power bank

DSC_9068

DSC_9069DSC_9071

This is a 18650 charger and power bank from Xtar.

DSC_9062DSC_9063DSC_9064DSC_9065

It arrived in a white cardboard box with a window in and some specification on it.

DSC_9066

The box contained the charger, a usb cable and a instruction sheet.

DSC_9074

The charger is usb powered with a micro usb input and a usb output for the power bank function.

DSC_9073

This button is used to turn the power bank on, this is only needed when checking the power level, it will automatic turn on when a load is connected.

DSC_9176

The display shows from 00 to 100, depending on how much capacity is in the power bank. While charging one of the digits will flash. When powered on or reset is will show a counting sequence: 00-11-22-33-44-55-66-77-88-99- for external usb power and 99-88-77-66-55-44-33-22-11- for internal battery power.

DSC_9070

The lid uses magnets, this makes it fairly easy to open when you stick you nail into a small slot. The magnets are strong enough that you can easily lift the box in the lid, when it is filled with batteries.

DSC_9072


supportedBatteryTypes
supportedBatterySizes

DSC_9075
DSC_9076

This charger only supports unprotected 18650 batteries.



Measurements


  • Power consumption from usb when idle with no batteries is 9mA
  • Will charge one battery with 2A
  • Will charge two batteries with down to 1A on each (Lowest voltage will get more current)
  • Will discharge a full battery with about 0.5mA when powered.
  • Will discharge a full battery with about 0.1mA when not powered.
  • Below 0.5V the charger will report error
  • Between 0.5 and 3V the charger will charge with low current (200-300mA)
  • Above 3V the charger will use full current.
  • Will not restart charging if voltage drops.
  • Will restart charging if battery is inserted.


Xtar%20PB2%20%28SA18650-33%29%20%231

A nice CC/CV charge curve with termination around 100mA

Xtar%20PB2%20%28SA18650-33%29%20%232

Second slot looks similar.

Xtar%20PB2%20%28PA18650-31%29%20%231
Xtar%20PB2%20%28SA18650-26%29%20%231

These two other batteries is also charged nicely.

Xtar%20PB2%20%282xSA18650-33%29

With two batteries the charge current drops to 1A to keep the usb input current at 2A.

Xtar%20PB2%200.5ohm%20%282xSA18650-33%29

Adding 0.5ohm resistance in series with the power supply to simulate a long cable or weak supply shows that the charger will reduce usb and charge current, but the charging works fine.

Temp5434

M1: 34.6°C, M2: 43.9°C, HS1: 45.0°C
There is some electronic inside the charger that gets a bit warm, but the battery box do not look warm.

Temp5435

M1: 37.2°C, M2: 37.3°C, HS1: 46.5°C
Batteries are below 40°C while I am charging with lid on, this is fine.

Temp5436

M1: 40.7°C, HS1: 51.7°C
And the hottest part of the charger electronic do not look very hot.

Poweron

The charger is very fast to start, it only needs about 1 seconds.



Power bank

  • Will discharge a full battery with about 0.1mA when not powered.
  • Usb output turns off after 45 seconds with load below 290mA, with no load it turns off after 10 seconds.
  • Usb input and output is not directly connected, no output voltage leaks to the usb input.
  • Cannot be used as a UPS, output turns off when usb power is removed.
  • Usb output is coded with usb charger (DCP)


Xtar%20PB2%20%28SA18650-33%29%20%231%20load%20sweep

With one battery the charger is rated for 1A and overload trips at 1.3A, this looks fine.
All load sweeps make a measurement at 0 then jumps to a bit above 300mA to avoid auto turnoff.

Xtar%20PB2%20%282xSA18650-33%29%20load%20sweep

With two batteries the rating is 2A and it can deliver a bit above 2.4A.

Xtar%20PB2%20%28no%20batteries%29%20load%20sweep

With no batteries in the charger, but usb power connected it passes the power through, but there is some voltage drop.

Xtar%20PB2%20%28empty%20battery%29%20load%20sweep

With one empty battery the charger will charge the battery, but keep the usb power draw at 2A, this is the reason for the low efficiency at low current.

Below efficiency curve is only valid with one battery in the charger

Xtar%20PB2%20usb%20out%2010ohm%20%28SA18650-33%29%20%231

As a power bank it can easily deliver 0.5A until the battery is down to about 3.2V, where it turns off.

Xtar%20PB2%20usb%20out%2010ohm%20%28SA18650-33%29%20%232

Second channel looks the same.

Xtar%20PB2%20usb%20out%2010ohm%20%282xSA18650-33%29

With two batteries the time is slight more than double up.

Xtar%20PB2%20usb%20out%205ohm%20%28SA18650-33%29%20%231

One battery can also handle 1A load and the voltage stays stable (more or less) until the battery is empty.
There is no overload protection here, charger depends on overload protection in the usb charger used to power it.

Xtar%20PB2%20usb%20out%205ohm%20%282xSA18650-33%29

With two batteries the time is again more than double.

Xtar%20PB2%20usb%20out%202.5ohm%20%282xSA18650-33%29

For 2A output two batteries are required.
The output voltage jumps up and down on all the curves, but stays within the required usb range.

10ohm

There is 24mV rms noise and 287mVpp noise.

5ohm

There is 157mV rms noise and 405mVpp noise.

2.5ohm

There is 72mV rms noise and 869mVpp noise.



Conclusion

This charger and power bank has a good size for a two battery device and the magnetic lid is easy to open. The charging looks good, but batteries must be able to handle 2A charge current.
The power bank has enough power to maintain output voltage, until the batteries are empty, the coding is also fine, but I could have wished for lower noise on the output, this jumping up/down in voltage may force some devices to a lower charger current.

I will rate is as a fairly good power bank and charger.



Notes

The charger was supplied by XTAR for a review.

Here is an explanation on how I did the above charge curves: How do I test a charger

My website with reviews of many chargers and batteries (More than 1000): https://lygte-info.dk/

Viewing all 322 articles
Browse latest View live